---------- Sent from my Nokia phone
------Original message------ From: John Ashworth <[email protected]> To: "Group" <[email protected]> Date: Sunday, February 12, 2012 10:47:07 AM GMT+0300 Subject: [sudan-john-ashworth] South Sudan goes for sovereignty 1. The South goes for sovereignty 3rd February 2012 Vol 53 N0 3 Africa Confidential (free material) Juba turns off the oil and turns up the pressure in its fraught negotiations with Khartoum over oil, cash, security and citizenship Few outside the Juba government had expected it to start shutting down oil production on 22 January. Warnings from the Government of South Sudan had been widely seen as brinkmanship. The National Congress Party (NCP), plus African Union, Chinese and Western mediators, had apparently forgotten the capacity for decisiveness of the Sudan People’s Liberation Movement (SPLM), which helped it to win Independence for the South. The talks should resume on 10 February but no one expects speedy agreement. This was clear when the AU representative, South African ex-President Thabo Mbeki, announced on 31 January that they would cover several outstanding issues from the 2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement since ‘the interim transitional period ends at the end of March’. This broadening of the agenda is a tactical victory for the GOSS, which for the first time has the NCP literally over a barrel. This is costing Khartoum dear but it also knows that Juba loses 98% of revenue, with no clear alternative. The NCP’s strength is military and it is beating the war drums. Second Vice-President El Haj Adam Yusuf said on 25 January that the army had surrounded SPLM-North rebels in Blue Nile and South Kordofan and ‘Juba is not far’. Until November, he was senior in Hassan Abdullah el Turabi’s Popular Congress Party and the NCP accused him of conspiracy in 2007. His threat has hardened Southern resolve and highlights the chasm between the two governments. ‘This is not about oil, it’s about politics!’ one senior Northern oppositionist told Africa Confidential. This goes even beyond the CPA’s ‘unfinished business’ to the heart of North-South relations on one hand and relations between the regime and the Sudanese people, North and South, on the other. ‘They [the NCP] have convinced themselves that the Independence of the South is just a formality,’ the oppositionist said. Khartoum has warned foreign journalists and rabidly anti-Southern propaganda has appeared even in liberal media, such as Al Ayyam. This all suggests two broad scenarios: the talks focus on technical and financial issues and reach agreement, at least on oil; or they break down and South Sudan seeks new outlets while Sudan’s economy nosedives. Either way, a new Southern pipeline looks likely (see Box, Who pays the pipeline). The bigger unknown is whether the NCP will apply its theoretical military superiority. Who will blink first? It doesn’t look as if the GOSS will blink first and much now depends on how the NCP assesses the economic crisis and its political impact. It was demanding up to US$38 a barrel from Juba in transit fees (the international rate is $0.40-$1.00) and confiscated already loaded ships at Port Sudan. It did not seem to be seeking compromise. President Salva Kiir Mayardit accused it of ‘looting’ $815 mn. in Southern oil, some through a new, secret, spur pipeline, and of underreporting output for years. As the talks ended, Juba had offered $1.7 billion to Khartoum and transit fees of $0.63-0.69 a barrel. Khartoum demanded $5.4 bn. cash and $3 a barrel. What has really upset Southerners is that Khartoum has dealt with Juba in the traditional way. President Omer Hassan Ahmed el Beshir called it ‘naive’ and Foreign Minister Ali Ahmed Kurti, ‘childish’. This is seen as a calculated insult to the new sovereignty for which Southerners have paid so dearly. ‘It’s OUR oil’, said one Southern analyst, ‘and it’s a separate country. They can’t demand things.’ Interested governments follow the oil crisis and the war in Blue Nile and Kordofan with anxiety and a steadfast public even-handedness which dismays Southerners and also Northerners, who regularly ask why Libyans rebelling against a brutal dictatorship get Western and Arab military support while their Sudanese counterparts receive only criticism. On the oil issue, the West is privately more sympathetic to the South, says an SPLM source. However, this may not extend to bailing out a government which has stopped pumping approximately 315,000 barrels per day. ‘Resolution is imperative if the GOSS is to have the wherewithal to be a development partner for the international community,’ warned a senior British official this week. Chinese puzzle China, the biggest producer and purchaser of Sudanese oil, is also worried and dispatched the head of the Communist Party Central Committee’s International Department, Wang Jiarui, to Juba and Khartoum. ‘The shutdown raises the political instability of an already challenging operating environment, pushing Chinese and other Asian national oil companies [Malaysian and Indian] to reconsider the importance of the two Sudans in their expanding international portfolios,’ Luke Patey, co-editor of a new book, Sudan Looks East, told AC. China gets only 5-6% of its oil from the Sudans but fears sanctions on major supplier Iran. The kidnapping of 25 Chinese workers in Egypt (now released) and the capture of 29 others by the SPLM-N during fighting with Sudan’s army in South Kordofan have triggered a public debate in China on workers’ protection, at least abroad. The 25 were building a road near Talodi (to facilitate gold mining by French interests, say Nuba sources). Beijing even deployed Vice-Foreign Minister Xie Hangsheng on 31 January to reprimand Sudanese Chargé Omer Eissa Ahmed. Meanwhile, though, China was trying to negotiate the workers’ safe passage with the SPLM-N, thereby opening relations with the opposition. The whole situation challenges Beijing’s huge new investment in unstable countries and its policy of ‘non-interference’. China analyst Daniel Large said: ‘It’s a very elastic policy – very hard to break.’ Beijing will not abandon Khartoum (it’s just promised a $200 million loan) or Juba. Its biggest decision may be whether to help build a Southern pipeline. General Salva Kiir’s team knows that challenging Khartoum is the most popular move it can make. People came out on the streets nationwide to support the oil shutdown but there is also concern about what comes next. Hopes of health and education remain high. This was no knee-jerk shutdown, say insiders, and the GOSS has long planned for the worst. Cabinet Affairs Minister Deng Alor Kuol spoke of a five-year cushion and other sources talk of a sovereign wealth fund banked in Kenya and Uganda. One key man in the Ethiopia talks has been Sayed Mohamed el Hassan el Khatib, an NCP trusty, ex-London diplomat and CPA negotiator. He also heads the NCP’s Centre for Strategic Studies: some rethinking may be required there as it seems Khartoum underestimated GOSS strategising. As both parties prepare for the next bout of talks, Juba faces the tough task of wresting substantive concessions from Khartoum’s veteran tacticians. There may be a messy compromise but that’s far from guaranteed. http://www.africa-confidential.com/article/id/4323/The_South_goes_for_sovereignty END1 2. Sudan Loads South Sudanese Crude Oil for Export, Documents Show 2012-02-10 16:38:07.762 GMT By Jared Ferrie and Sherry Su Feb. 10 (Bloomberg) -- Sudan ordered oil companies to load 2.6 million barrels of South Sudanese crude for export last month without its neighbor’s authority, according to documents obtained by Bloomberg News. The African nation put 1.9 million barrels of Dar Blend onto three tankers, comprised of 650,000 barrels on the Sea Sky, 750,000 barrels on the Al Nouf and 600,000 barrels on the ETC Isis, letters provided by the office of Pagan Amum, the southern government’s chief negotiator with Sudan, showed. Sudan also loaded 600,000 barrels of Nile Blend on to the Ratna Sharada, the documents showed. South Sudan gained independence from its northern neighbor on July 9, gaining control of about 75 percent of the formerly united country’s 490,000 barrels-a-day of output. Negotiations since then have failed to yield an agreement on how much the south should pay for the use of Sudan’s export pipeline. The latest round of talks began today in Addis Ababa, the Ethiopian capital. The disputed crude is worth about $280 million. Greater Nile Petroleum Operating Co. loaded the Ratna Sharada, while Petrodar Operating Co., an oil-pipeline operator in Sudan, was instructed to fill the other three tankers, according to the documents. Al-Obeid Murawih, a spokesman for the Sudanese Foreign Ministry in Khartoum, didn’t answer a phone call by Bloomberg seeking comment. “This action is certainly not acceptable as the crude belongs to Republic of South Sudan government and prior approval from RSS is therefore needed,” Liu Yingcai, president of Petrodar, said in an letter to officials of oil ministries in both countries on Jan. 30, referring to the loading of a Dar Blend cargo on the ETC Isis. ‘Physically Removed’ The shipment of Dar Blend onto the Sea Sky was enforced by the government of Sudan’s security forces and was completed Jan. 14, Liu said in a separate letter. “Our PDOC staff in Marine Terminal had been threatened to be physically removed if they do not comply with the loading activities,” he said. South Sudan produced about 260,000 barrels a day in December, while Sudan pumped 110,000 barrels, according to the International Energy Agency. China imported about 260,000 barrels from the two countries last year and will probably be most affected by the disruption, the IEA said today in its monthly oil market report. An official at Petrodar, who declined to be identified citing company policy, declined to comment on the matter. A call to Greater Nile’s office in Khartoum wasn’t answered. The Ratna Sharada loaded crude from Bashayer, Sudan, on Jan. 18 to Jan. 20 and arrived in Singapore this week, according to ship-tracking data from AISLive Ltd. compiled by Bloomberg. Shutting Production South Sudan started shutting oil production on Jan. 23 amid a deepening dispute with its northern neighbor over transportation fees for its crude exports. Before the halt, South Sudan’s oil was pumped mainly by China National Petroleum Corp., Malaysia’s Petroliam Nasional Bhd. and India’s Oil and National Gas Co. The current negotiations will cover all issues outstanding since separation, including the status of the disputed territory of Abyei and undemarcated sections of the border, Barnaba Marial Benjamin, a South Sudanese government spokesman, said by phone yesterday from Juba, the country’s capital. The talks will include a “forum” involving both governments, as well as CNPC and ONGC, he said. “In the absence of a foreseeable resolution, we have also reduced production estimates by around 200,000 barrels a day in the first quarter of 2012 and by 100,000 barrels a day for 2012, reflecting landlocked South Sudan’s export conundrum,” the Paris-based IEA said in the report. END2 3. Trafigura deals in disputed Sudanese oil Wed Feb 8, 2012 9:13am GMT * South Sudan says three tankers were seized by Khartoum * Trafigura bought one cargo of disputed oil * Trafigura says made "significant effort" to establish ownership * FAL Oil manages two tankers of disputed oil By Emma Farge GENEVA, Feb 8 (Reuters) - Swiss-based commodities trader Trafigura has bought oil which the South Sudanese government claims was seized by Sudan, its northern neighbour and former civil war foe, industry sources told Reuters, and is now in a legal dispute over ownership. The tanker of crude oil is one of three seized cargoes forming part of some $815 million in oil revenues that South Sudan's President Salva Kiir accused Sudan of "looting" and which the government in Khartoum said provided compensation for unpaid transit fees. Landlocked, war-ravaged South Sudan must pump its oil to the Red Sea via a pipeline across Sudan to Port Sudan to earn oil revenues which account for 98 percent of the seven-month-old country's income. Last month, South Sudan shut down its 350,000 barrels per day of production in an escalating row over the three cargoes. Sudan's President Omar Hassan al-Bashir said in an interview on Friday tensions with South Sudan over oil transit payments could lead to war between the two countries. Trafigura, the world's third largest oil trader, bought one cargo of the Nile Blend grade crude loaded aboard the Indian-flagged 'Ratna Shradha', industry sources familiar with the transaction said. The fate of the other two cargoes is unclear. South Sudanese authorities said this vessel loaded 600,000 barrels of oil in Sudan provided by Khartoum-based oil producer Greater Nile Petroleum Operating Company between January 19-20. There is, however, no indication that GNPOC, led by China's CNPC, had a role in marketing the oil. Several CNPC officials in Beijing either declined to comment or declined any knowledge of the transaction. TRAFIGURA STATEMENT In response to a request for information about Trafigura's involvement with this shipment, the firm said in an emailed statement last week: "Like many oil companies, we have bought from time to time both Nile Blend and Dar Blend crude oil. In relation to our interests in recent shipments, given the ongoing political discussions with respect to Sudanese oil ownership, significant efforts have been made to confirm legal title, and that confirmation has been provided." "The Government of Southern Sudan were asked to provide further information to support their claim to ownership of the oil in which Trafigura has an interest. Some information has been provided which we are reviewing," the statement said. The Trafigura shipment loaded on 19-20 January, days before the South Sudan's justice ministry published a list of three vessels - Ratna Shradha, Sea Sky and Al Nouf - it said had been forced to load southern oil on orders from Khartoum. Earlier on Jan 14. it stated that Sudan had loaded oil of Southern Sudanese origin on the 'Sea Sky'. Sudan confirmed a day before that it was holding two other ships with southern oil over unpaid fees. It did not say whether it intended to sell the oil, nor did it state the volumes, saying only that the oil would be used in its two refineries. Oil and metals trading giant Trafigura, whose chairman Claude Dauphin was a protege of veteran oil trader Marc Rich, is well-known in commodity circles. The company has drawn international scrutiny twice in recent years: for oil trade with Iraq under the United Nations' oil-for-food programme and the dumping of toxic oil waste in the Ivory Coast. A Trafigura-chartered tanker was intercepted in the Caribbean in 2001 on suspicion of carrying illegal Iraqi crude. In a settlement, Trafigura agreed to pay a $5 million fine, but was not charged with smuggling and denied wrongdoing. More recently, a tanker it chartered in 2006 dumped toxic waste in Ivory Coast. The government of Ivory Coast alleged that 16 died and thousands were made ill. Trafigura paid a $200 million settlement and the country's prosecutor declared there was no evidence of any illegality by Trafigura. SHIPPED TO ASIA Trafigura declined to comment further when asked if the company had any concerns about the origins of the disputed Sudanese oil shipment before the decision to buy or load it. Reuters has no independent confirmation to support South Sudan's claim that its oil was stolen. However, it is exceptional for Sudan to market its 115,000 barrels per day of production as this is normally processed in domestic refineries. Sudan has not sold any other oil since July when South Sudan was established. The Ratna Shradha was last seen on February 5 near Singapore and listed its destination as the Malaysian port of Tanjung Pelepas, according to AIS Live ship tracking data on Reuters. South Sudan's oil is typically sent east to Asian refineries. South Sudan's justice ministry in the capital Juba has warned that any party purchasing these three cargoes or selling to another party may be liable to litigation. A lawyer advising clients on energy sanctions said that third parties involved in dealing with any seized South Sudanese oil could be sued by Southern authorities and that a contract to buy the oil might not serve as a defence in a court of law. "It's like having a dispute over whether the cost of the cloak room is one pound or two pounds and then they sell your coat. This is almost certainly illegal to sell the oil and any third party involved could risk civil liability," said the lawyer, who asked not to named. The Ratna Shradha is owned by a Calcutta-based company called India Steamship. An official at the company, who did not wish to be identified, confirmed that Trafigura had loaded the crude oil onto the Ratna Shradha. He said he was not aware of any legal complications arising from the transaction. The price of the oil sold to Trafigura is not known. But traders in the Middle East and Asia said that the disputed cargoes were offered from Port Sudan at discounts to official prices charged by South Sudan. "We never comment about transactions in which we have an interest, other than to say that the pricing of any commodity deal is always determined by many factors including, for example, storage capacity onshore and availability of shipping capacity," Trafigura said in a statement on Monday. At current international oil prices the 600,000 barrel load is worth around $70 million. < IRAN CONNECTION Trafigura is not the only company that has been involved with the disputed oil shipments. Middle East-based trader FAL Oil is managing the two other oil tankers that South Sudan claims were illegally seized and sold by Khartoum on the international oil market, the industry sources said and FAL Oil confirmed to Reuters. The sources said that the other disputed shipments aboard the 'Al Nouf' and the 'Sea Sky' that loaded Dar Blend oil in mid-January have not yet found final buyers. AIS Live tracking data showed that one of the tankers, the Sea Sky, was anchored off the shore of Sudan on 5 February while the Al Nouf has not sent a satellite signal in recent weeks. FAL Oil General Manager Mohamed Osman told Reuters last week: "We are managing the ships, but we are not the charterers. The cargo is not ours. But we can't disclose the charterer. At the moment we don't know what the charterer would like to do." The company has been one of the largest independent oil and bunker traders in the Gulf, although it has scaled back trading operations in the past 18 months due to credit issues. Earlier this month, U.S. authorities imposed sanctions on FAL Oil for links with the Iranian oil sector in an effort to increase pressure over Iran's nuclear programme. FAL Oil says the sanctions are based on a misunderstanding and that it is working with the U.S. authorities to seek a quick lifting of the measures. Global Witness, a campaigning group focusing on the abuse of wealth in resource-rich countries, condemned the involvement of FAl Oil in the Sudanese shipments. "The company needs to come clean on its role in loading and transporting these disputed shipments. FAL should explain who they have been dealing with and where the money is," Global Witness director Gavin Hayman said in an emailed statement. (Additional reporting by Humeyra Pamuk in Dubai, Nidhi Verma in New Delhi, Jim Bai in Beijing, Ulf Laessing and Alexander Dziadosz in Khartoum; Editing by Peter Millership, Richard Mably) http://af.reuters.com/article/sudanNews/idAFL5E8D82R620120208?sp=true END3 4. Trafigura linked to oil 'looted' from South Sudan Commodities trader has bought containers of crude Sudan seized from its southern neighbour, industry insiders say guardian.co.uk, Wednesday 8 February 2012 12.05 GMT The Swiss-based commodities trader Trafigura has bought oil the South Sudanese government claims was seized by Sudan, its northern neighbour and former civil war enemy, according to industry sources. Trafigura is now in a legal dispute over ownership, the sources told Reuters. The tanker of crude oil is one of three seized cargoes, forming part of some $815m (£512m) in oil revenues, which South Sudan's president, Salva Kiir, accused Sudan of "looting"; the Sudanese government, in Khartoum, said the cargoes provided compensation for unpaid transit fees. Landlocked South Sudan must pump its oil to the Red Sea via a pipeline across Sudan, to Port Sudan, to earn oil revenues, which account for 98% of the seven-month-old country's income. Last month, South Sudan shut down its production of 350,000 barrels a day in an escalating row over the three cargoes. Sudan's president, Omar Hassan al-Bashir, said in an interview on Friday tensions with South Sudan over oil transit payments could lead to war between the two countries. Trafigura, the world's third-largest oil trader, bought one cargo of the Nile Blend grade crude, loaded aboard the Indian-flagged Ratna Shradha, according to industry sources familiar with the transaction. The fate of the other two cargoes is unclear. In response to a request for information about Trafigura's involvement with this shipment, the firm said in an emailed statement last week: "Like many oil companies, we have bought from time to time both Nile Blend and Dar Blend crude oil. In relation to our interests in recent shipments, given the ongoing political discussions with respect to Sudanese oil ownership, significant efforts have been made to confirm legal title, and that confirmation has been provided. "The government of Southern Sudan were asked to provide further information to support their claim to ownership of the oil in which Trafigura has an interest. Some information has been provided, which we are reviewing." The Trafigura shipment loaded days before the South Sudanese justice ministry published a list of three vessels – Ratna Shradha, Sea Sky and Al Nouf – it said had been forced to load southern oil on orders from Khartoum. Earlier, on 14 January, it stated that Sudan had loaded oil of Southern Sudanese origin on to the Sea Sky. Sudan confirmed a day before that it was holding two other ships with southern oil over unpaid fees. It did not say whether it intended to sell the oil; nor did it state the volumes, saying only that the oil would be used in its two refineries. The oil and metals trading giant Trafigura, whose chairman, Claude Dauphin, was a protegé of the veteran oil trader Marc Rich, is well known in commodity circles. The company has drawn international scrutiny twice in recent years: for oil trade with Iraq under the United Nations' oil-for-food programme, and in connection with the dumping of toxic oil waste in the Ivory Coast. A Trafigura-chartered tanker was intercepted in the Caribbean in 2001 on suspicion of carrying illegal Iraqi crude. In a settlement, Trafigura agreed to pay a $20m penalty, but was not charged with smuggling and denied wrongdoing. More recently, toxic waste from a tanker it chartered in 2006 was dumped in Ivory Coast. The case was settled after Trafigura agreed to make payments to the victims, although it did not accept legal liability. An agreed joint statement was issued by Trafigura and lawyers representing the claimants in the Ivory Coast, which confirmed the conclusions reached by scientific experts appointed in the case. The joint statement described the consequences of the waste dumping as at worst being "low-level" illness, as opposed to deaths, miscarriages or more serious injuries. Trafigura declined to comment further when asked if the company had any concerns about the origins of the disputed Sudanese oil shipment before the decision to buy or load it. Reuters said it had no independent confirmation to support South Sudan's claim that its oil was stolen. However, it is exceptional for Sudan to market its 115,000 barrels a day of production as this is normally processed in domestic refineries. Sudan has not sold any other oil since July, when South Sudan was established. The Ratna Shradha was last seen on 5 February, near Singapore, and listed its destination as the Malaysian port of Tanjung Pelepas, according to ship tracking data. South Sudan's oil is typically sent east to Asian refineries. South Sudan's justice ministry in the capital, Juba, has warned that any party purchasing these three cargoes or selling to another party may be liable to litigation. The Ratna Shradha is owned by a Calcutta-based company called India Steamship. An official at the company, who did not wish to be identified, confirmed that Trafigura had loaded the crude oil on to the Ratna Shradha. He said he was not aware of any legal complications arising from the transaction. The price of the oil sold to Trafigura is not known. But traders in the Middle East and Asia said the disputed cargoes were offered from Port Sudan at discounts to official prices charged by South Sudan. "We never comment about transactions in which we have an interest, other than to say that the pricing of any commodity deal is always determined by many factors including, for example, storage capacity onshore and availability of shipping capacity," Trafigura said in a statement. At current international oil prices, the 600,000-barrel load is worth around $70m. Trafigura is not the only company that has been involved with the disputed oil shipments. The Middle East-based trader FAL Oil is managing the two other oil tankers South Sudan claims were illegally seized and sold by Khartoum on the international oil market, the industry sources said. The sources said the other disputed shipments aboard the Al Nouf and the Sea Sky that loaded Dar Blend oil in mid-January had not yet found final buyers. Tracking data showed that one of the tankers, the Sea Sky, was anchored off the shore of Sudan on 5 February while the Al Nouf has not sent a satellite signal in recent weeks. FAL Oil's general manager, Mohamed Osman, said last week: "We are managing the ships, but we are not the charterers. The cargo is not ours, but we can't disclose the charterer. At the moment, we don't know what the charterer would like to do." The company has been one of the largest independent oil and bunker traders in the Gulf, although it has scaled back trading operations in the past 18 months because of credit issues. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/feb/08/trafigura-oil-south-sudan END4 5. Diplomatic community should act now to help resolve oil dispute between the Sudans Global Witness 10th February 2012 The African Union, China, and western governments must push for an immediate resolution to the ongoing oil dispute between Sudan and South Sudan, said Global Witness today. The call comes as the two sides resume talks in the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa, and amidst heightened tension and talk of war. Sudan and South Sudan have been engaged in protracted talks to determine the transit of South Sudan’s oil for export via Sudan’s infrastructure. A failure to reach a new deal has led to dramatic unilateral action from both sides within the last month. This includes the confiscation of South Sudan’s crude oil by Sudan in lieu of transit fees, and South Sudan’s subsequent decision to implement a full shut down of its production and seek alternative export routes. Public exchanges between the governments have become increasingly tense, both referring to the possibility of renewed war, as they appear to be preparing for confrontation along the border. “The AU, China, the US, UK, and Norway in particular must engage at the highest diplomatic levels to broker a deal between the two sides,” said Global Witness campaigner Dana Wilkins. “The longer this dispute goes on and both economies continue to suffer, the more likely it is that the situation will escalate.” In mid-January, Sudan began confiscating South Sudanese crude oil, including redirecting consignments reportedly worth more than $250 million which were destined for four oil tankers at Port Sudan. This follows action by Sudan to block several ships from entering or leaving the port. The Government of South Sudan responded by shutting down all production in its territory. As a result, neither country will have access to revenues from oil that they are so reliant on. It is unclear how either country can compensate for the loss of revenues resulting from these actions. The oil sector provides for more than 98% of South Sudan’s annual Budget. The IMF estimates that, separate from this new dispute, the secession of South Sudan will cost Sudan more than $7.7 billion in lost revenues over the next four years. Prior to the shut down, South Sudan produced around 350,000 barrels per day, more than three-quarters of a united Sudan’s oil production. But the processing facilities, pipelines, and marine terminals necessary to export remain within the territory of Sudan. “If this were a region of the world deemed to be of greater strategic importance, we would have already seen a more coordinated, robust, and high-level push from the international community to prevent the situation from deteriorating this far,” said Wilkins. “This effort needs to happen now and must include pushing for assurances of transparency and independent verification in any new oil deal. Without this, the intense mistrust which has fuelled the current dispute will come up time and time again.” http://www.globalwitness.org/library/diplomatic-community-should-act-now-help-resolve-oil-dispute-between-sudans END5 6. Sudans’ Oil Feud Risks Shattering a Fragile Peace NYT By JEFFREY GETTLEMAN Published: February 10, 2012 KHARTOUM, Sudan — Sudan and the breakaway nation of South Sudan have been locked in an exceedingly dangerous game of brinkmanship over billions of gallons of oil, seizing tankers, shutting down wells and imperiling the tenuous, American-backed peace that has held — just barely — between the two countries after decades of war. Not for years have north-south relations been so poisonous, with a proxy war between the two nations fueling rebel groups and sometimes even flaring into direct Sudan-South Sudan clashes. The jagged, disputed frontier separating Sudan from its newly independent neighbor is now probably the most incendiary fault line in Africa, with two big armies that fought each other for generations massing on either side. After emergency talks to prevent a full-fledged conflict, the two sides agreed to a vague nonaggression pact late on Friday, yielding to intense pressure from the African Union, the United States and China — a major oil partner for both sides — to move beyond the language and tactics of mutual destruction. But few analysts see any easy solutions to the heated push and pull over oil, and it is not clear how the nonaggression pact will be any different from previous security deals that have led nowhere. In May, the two sides agreed to demilitarize the contested border. But just days after that, Sudan began heavy bombardment along the border, occasionally dropping bombs in the south, while the South Sudanese rushed in weapons to rebel allies fighting just across the divide. The border area has been a tinderbox for years because that is where most of the oil lies. Both sides desperately need oil to run their governments, feed their people and stamp out spreading rebellions. And theoretically, both sides need each other. The conundrum of the two Sudans is that 75 percent of the oil is in the south, just across the border, but the pipeline to export it runs through the north. Because of this, oil was once thought to be the glue that would hold the two nations together and prevent a conflict. Now, it seems, oil is becoming the fuse. When South Sudan broke off from Sudan last year, after years of guerrilla struggle, its independence was heralded as the triumphal capstone ending one of Africa’s deadliest civil wars. But the question of how exactly the two sides would share oil profits loomed ominously over the separation, unresolved. Now that both nations are struggling to make it on their own, the issue has proved to be as prickly — and perilous — as many feared. It was South Sudanese oil that drove Sudan’s economic boom of the past decade and made the repression by Sudan’s Islamist government (which is still heavily penalized by the United States) tolerable to many Sudanese. When South Sudan declared independence, it took oil worth billions of dollars with it, gutting Sudan’s economy and creating one of the deepest crises that President Omar Hassan al-Bashir has faced in his more than 20 years in power. Mr. Bashir is now battling high inflation, a shrinking economy, student protests and several simultaneous rebellions — in Darfur, the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile State — as well as genocide charges related to the massacres several years ago in Darfur, and stiff American sanctions. At the same time, South Sudan, one of the world’s poorest countries, is facing a major food crisis and heavily armed ethnically based militias that have been sweeping parts of the countryside, killing hundreds and making a mockery of the South Sudanese security forces. Stoking the tensions, Sudan and South Sudan have been covertly backing rebels in each other’s backyards, leading to border clashes and relentless aerial bombings. The more than 1,000-mile border between them is now effectively closed, with millions of pounds of emergency food and just about all trade held up in a two-way stranglehold. Before the emergency accord on Friday, the situation was so precarious that many saw only violent outcomes. “I, personally, expect full-fledged war,” said Mariam al-Sadiq al-Mahdi, a leading opposition politician in Khartoum, Sudan’s capital. “This is like the previews before a film.” In the fight over oil, the south has refused to turn over royalties for using Sudan’s pipelines. Sudan upped the ante in late December by seizing oil tankers filled with South Sudanese crude. Then the south took the drastic step of abruptly shutting down all of its oil wells, a measure that could quickly bring the economies of both north and south to their knees. South Sudanese officials have admitted they are using their oil to squeeze Khartoum to make concessions on all sorts of issues, including the disputed area of Abyei, insisting that oil production, about 350,000 barrels a day, will resume only after “all the deals are signed.” The south has even threatened to sit on its oil for years while it builds an alternative pipeline through Kenya. But it is not clear how the new country will survive that long; oil provides about 98 percent of government revenue. And experts question whether the Kenya pipeline is even feasible. It would have to run uphill, requiring many expensive pumping stations, and most likely slice across Jonglei, a South Sudanese state that, with all its militias, is essentially a war zone. In Khartoum, many people are still struggling to swallow the fact that the south is gone. Nobody likes the new map of Sudan. It used to be Africa’s biggest country. Now it looks as if it has been crudely amputated, left with the ragged edges of a raw wound. “I still can’t get used to it,” said Nada Gerais, a sales manager in Khartoum. “It looks, looks ...,” she struggled for the right word. “Weird.” Mrs. Gerais is a perfect example of the nose dive Sudan’s economy has taken. She works in a meticulously polished Nissan dealership that used to sell 50 cars a month. Now, sometimes, it is down to five. She is thinking of switching to pharmaceuticals or food. “People can stop buying cars, but they can’t stop eating,” she explained. During the past decade, Sudan’s oil wealth helped build factories, roads and countless shish kebab joints, and it fueled plans for a futuristic minicity, a new airport and a reconfiguring of Khartoum to include a breezy promenade along the Nile. But now high-rise buildings stand half-finished, and the plummeting value of the Sudanese pound has pushed electronics, books and even tomatoes out of reach for many. Officials in Khartoum say the south owes them nearly $1 billion in pipeline fees, money needed to keep their economy from collapsing, and they recently sold some of the oil from the seized tankers before releasing them. South Sudan’s president, Salva Kiir, said the amount Khartoum wanted, $32 per barrel, was “exorbitant” and “completely out of international norms.” Sabir M. Hassan, a Sudanese government negotiator, said that the north was willing to be flexible, but that the southerners were “too emotional” and still saw themselves as rebels. “If you give them two choices, they’ll choose the one that hurts the north, not the one that helps the south,” Mr. Hassan said. South Sudanese leaders say the same about Khartoum, which has blockaded roads leading south and recently held up humanitarian shipments, all to punish the south at the cost of millions of dollars in lost business. Many political analysts wonder whether Mr. Bashir will be able to survive these crises. But it is hard to see who would replace him. Sudan’s political opposition is deeply divided and run by white-bearded septuagenarians. The rebel movements do not have much support in Khartoum. Sudanese students started an Arab Spring-like movement last year, but they failed to gain any traction. The security forces were quick to arrest protesters and string them up from ceiling fans. And Sudan has a resilience that transcends the turmoil. Every Friday, in a dusty ring on Khartoum’s outskirts, hundreds of Nuban men gather to watch traditional wrestling. Ethnic Nubans are leading the rebellion in the Nuba Mountains. But there is little evidence of that here. “Things are fine,” said one elderly spectator. Just as he was about to elaborate, a young wrestler scooped up his opponent and body-slammed him in the dirt. “You see that!” the old man hollered. “My God, I love this.” http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/11/world/africa/sudan-and-south-sudan-edge-closer-to-brink-in-oil-dispute.html?_r=1 END6 ______________________ John Ashworth Sudan, South Sudan Advisor [email protected] +254 725 926 297 (Kenya mobile) +211 919 695 362 (South Sudan mobile) +27 82 050 1235 (South Africa mobile) +44 750 304 1790 (UK/international) +88 216 4334 0735 (Thuraya satphone) PO Box 52002 - 00200, Nairobi, Kenya This is a personal e-mail address and the contents do not necessarily reflect the views of any organisation -- The content of this message does not necessarily reflect John Ashworth's views. Unless explicitly stated otherwise, John Ashworth is not the author of the content and the source is always cited. You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "sudan-john-ashworth" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.co.za/group/sudan-john-ashworth -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob?hl=en.
