Attacks on IDP Camps in Kutum Locality, North Darfur, Sudan Implications for Humanitarian Response and US Policy By Susan Burgess-Lent Kutum town and surrounding IDP camps and villages in North Darfur, Sudan were repeatedly attacked, looted and, in some cased, burned down during a period from August 2 - 6, 2012. These serious events have critical and urgent implications for humanitarian aid and for US policy in Sudan. This article contains two sections: 1. A synopsis of news reports from Radio Dabanga and from official statements released through relevant organizations and ministries; 2. An analysis and commentary by Susan Burgess-Lent, former Program Director of Darfur Peace and Development Organization (DPDO). From 2007 through 2011, Susan completed six missions to Kassab camp. During those periods of work, she developed many relationships within the camp that enabled an intimate understanding of the dynamics of the communities as well as the organizations associated with them. Synopsis of News Reports Aug 7 - 12, 2012 Reported scope of attacks: Kutum town, Kassab IDP camp, Fata Barno IDP camp, Kabkabiya IDP camp, the villages (south-east of Kutum) of Kourgui, Tinger Yiai, Jmboli, Biri and Tininin (See map) Perpetrators: >From witnesses via Radio Dabanga: Pro-government militia. >From Kassab camp committee: The [Khartoum] government is fully responsible for the recent attacks. >From multiple sources: Gunmen affiliated to the notorious Janjaweed militias following the assassination on 1 August of a local official linked to an Arab ethnic group. Reported Killed: 21 Reported Injured: estimates range from 40 to 600 Missing: Thousands Displaced: estimates range from 30,000 - 70,000 The majority of people who fled the camps are now living in the open without any food or medicine, while others are crammed in houses in Kutum town. Thousands are roaming in search for shelter and food in the rain, without proper clothing. Damage: Households looted, livestock stolen, homes and community centers looted or destroyed (destruction particularly in Fata Barno camp); humanitarian organizations' stores of food and fuel looted. Community status: Schools and government institutions remain closed. Although some shops and markets are partially open, basic commodities are scarce or lacking and the prices of basic goods rose sharply. UN staff evacuated to El Fasher. Response: A committee of Kassab IDPs condemned UNAMID's alleged failure in protecting unarmed civilians. They consider the recent events a serious development of policies from the Sudanese government and its militias towards IDP camps and citizens of surrounding areas… a new approach to ethnic cleansing and genocide. They issued a statement on Thursday [Aug 9] saying that “pro-government militias had conducted serious crimes that violated international, humanitarian and divine laws.” The statement condemned the UN-AU peacekeeping mission in the region (UNAMID) for failing to act on its mandate of protecting civilians just as the government failed to protect them. Tahir Ismail, sheikh of the Kassab camp, told Radio Dabanga about the lack of protection of IDPs and citizens and problems relating to lack of food, clothing, medicine, blankets and mosquito nets. He said that the following organizations participated in the meeting on Wednesday [Aug 8]: OCHA, WFP, Red Cross, UNICEF and the WHO. He expressed his concern for UNAMID's absence, as one of its responsibilities is to protect IDPs. It was reported that UNAMID did not meet any of the IDP leaders since the outbreak of the recent atrocities. A camp's leader reported that during the meeting other humanitarian organizations committed to Kutum Attacks Susan Burgess-Lent 8/14/12 2 of 4 rehabilitate IDPs' homes destroyed by pro-government militia. They will also provide food for the IDPs who fled the camp. The head of UNAMID invited IDPs to return to their homes in Kassab and Fatta Barno. (See Gambari below) An IDP leader assured Gambari and the other organizations that they will not return to Kassab and Fatta Barno until the provision of food and security on the ground and the rehabilitation of homes, as promised by them, are implemented. An undisclosed source from the Kassab camp said that around a thousand IDPs returned to the camp yesterday to check on their homes Abdul Nasser Ibrahim, head of civil society organizations in Kutum, appealed to the Sudanese Ministry of Justice to form a committee to investigate the recent events, to bring the perpetrators to trial as well as to disarm pro-government militias. He described the events as extremely dangerous and called upon humanitarian organizations for an immediate intervention and to help those who fled. “There is a great lack of food, medicine, drinking water and tents.” The Sudanese Committee for the Defense of Rights and Freedoms (SCDRF): The events that occurred last week in Kassab IDP camp in Kutum area of North Darfur State have created “dangerous humanitarian conditions requiring urgent intervention to prevent them from worsening." SCDRF’s monitoring coordinator, Abd Allah Adam Khatir underscored the gravity of Kutum events by saying they represent a national security threat and created a humanitarian situation in need of urgent intervention. The Head of the Ministry Committee responsible for monitoring and resolving the situation in Kutum town, El Fateh Abdel Aziz Abdel Nabi, said the SAF has full control of the situation. He explained the SAF secured all ways in and out of Kutum as well as the market and living areas. Nabi, who is also the Sudanese Minister of Urban Planning and Deputy Governor of North Darfur, added that the Committee's doors are open to Kutum citizens for inquiries and complaints. Ibrahim Gambari, the Joint Special Representative and head of the UNAMID peacekeeping mission, calls on the Sudanese government to investigate the attacks. UNAMID stated it sent a team to assess the situation and the needs of the population at the Kassab IDP camp and in Kutum. In addition, it deployed “a 24/7 protection force “ to IDP camps to protect the population. Among his promises, Gambari said that centers and gates would be placed within 24 hours on Kassab and Fatta Barno. This will control who enters and leaves the camps and prevent that weapons are brought inside the areas. UNAMID said on Thursday that it began in collaboration with the World Health Organization (WHO), the North Darfur Ministry of Health and the Kutum Rural Hospital, the delivery of medical assistance to over 170 persons in Kassab camp. Tijani Sese (Sissi), President of Darfur Regional Authority in Khartoum, demands that camps' leaders work to secure the camps and that they participate in resolving the conflict. Analysis and Commentary My experience in Kassab derives from creating and sustaining a Center for the women in the camp. That Center has been looted. I’ve received word that the staff and, I assume, many of the women of the Center, are alive but living in miserable conditions – a reprise of the first displacement at least seven year ago. This event is one of my worst fears finally and terribly realized. Though I am a khwaja (white foreigner), I slowly became part of this community. In fact, I think of them as family. Of necessity, ordinary people in the camp will only comment anonymously on events like this, knowing they risk detention and/or murder if revealed. Understanding the larger issues represented by disparate comments is our job. My particular role is to examine the comments and behavior of the various parties in light of what I personally know from being there. The attacks have occurred during Ramadan, a time when fasting further depletes people already living on short rations. A perfect storm of news distractions – the US election, the debacle in Syria, the Olympics, to Kutum Attacks Susan Burgess-Lent 8/14/12 3 of 4 name a few – coupled with the Khartoum government’s denial of media access and press censorship, allow this horror to occur without a blip on the radar of major news media. Further, the government is adept at limiting and jamming cell communications. The fewer who see and know what is happening, the less likely is response from those who could and should be taking concrete steps to make it stop. UNAMID has a large, well-secured and well-supplied base within a couple of miles of Kassab camp. (I’ve been billeted there.) It’s unbelievable that they would need “24 hours” to muster a response. One of my colleagues who spoke with the Kassab Women’s Center manager learned that UNAMID closed their gates against a rush of people fleeing the attacks. That UNAMID can manage to address the needs of only 170 of the estimated 600 people injured belies their own capacity to muster medical resources. The IDPs regard UNAMID with contempt for their inability to offer even the appearance of protection to civilians. Knowing that they report to Khartoum has created deep distrust – as it should. A symptom of the AU’s acquiescence to Khartoum was well illustrated during the planning of the AU’s summit in July. Joyce Banda, President of Malawi, the planned site, refused to allow Sudanese President Omar El Bashir into the country. She cited Malawi’s obligation, as signatory of the Rome Statute, to hand over indicted war criminals to the ICC. Since March 2009, Omar Bashir has been under indictment for crimes against humanity, war crimes and genocide in Darfur. Rather than dis-invite Bashir, the AU moved its summit to Addis Ababa. Gambari and UNAMID are no friends of Darfur. The Sudanese Armed Forces' (SAF) “full control” of the area around Kutum would be cause for enormous anxiety; the camp population knows them as the facilitators of attacks. More alarming is the move to create “centers and gates” to monitor the comings and goings of the IDPs. They will see it for what it is: a system to gather information for “final sweep” of the camp. How could they go back to the remnants of their “homes” with such threatening obstacles in place? The call for an investigation is a pro forma response. In reality, there are never investigations of attacks; the Sudanese judiciary has seen the resignation of two judges tasked with investigating crimes in Darfur. The locals in Kassab know from experience with epidemic rape and murder that there will be no judicial recourse for the crimes committed against them. They do, however, know their rights via a UNDPsponsored Rule of law program administered by DPDO in Kassab camp in 2010-11. All the more reason for them to feel the sting of the government’s indifference and impunity. When I was in Darfur in 2011, my organization, DPDO was essentially the last NGO left standing. All the others had been forced out – the first group of large organizations in March 2009 and then subsequent eviction of smaller ones for specious charges, at the pleasure of the Sudanese Humanitarian Aid Commission (HAC), a functionary of the security services. Over time, the remaining UN agencies have suffered and, some allege, bent to the intimidation of the Khartoum government regarding reporting of conditions and populations affected in Darfur. Tijani Sese (Sissi), President of the Darfur Regional Authority and the luckless “implementer” of the Doha Darfur Peace Document (DDPD) signed in July 2011, has not received funds to do the work because Khartoum has failed to honor its commitments to pay an initial $200 million for reconstruction and financial compensations to those affected by the conflict. And now Mr. Sese is asking the victims to take on the burden of securing the camps and resolving a “conflict” that was none of their making. Will sufficient aid be delivered to keep this group of people alive? If so, can the newly displaced go back to the camp and rebuild? These are important questions with dangerous answers. The government’s strategy for Darfur has never included a thought for “rehabilitation.” The long-term goal has always been the elimination of the indigenous, non-Arab tribes. The plan to “empty” the camps has been in the wind for at least two years, awaiting the right time and circumstances for execution. The “Warsaw ghettoes” of Sudan are now being emptied. The people who’ve survived many years in IDP camps will not be sent to gas chambers. They’ll be forced into a forbidding desert without food, water or shelter. They have nowhere to go. Government-sponsored squatters have appropriated their lands. There are no schools or clinics or other infrastructure to support their survival. Kutum Attacks Susan Burgess-Lent 8/14/12 4 of 4
-- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
