Chris,

You can have big walk-in closets in an apartment as easily as in an
SFD or a high-rise penthouse. In each case, whether to 13, 13R or 13D,
there are exceptions or not for closets and if not excepted then you
sprinkler the closet to the same conditions you would the rest of the
dwelling. You don't call a room that is accessible from the rest of
the dwelling outside of the dwelling because it could be used for
storage or a common laundry. What if this was an SFD that had been
converted to four apartments with a common kitchen, bath, pantry,
dining, living (which if I recall the original post from George it is)
would you call the single shared bathroom outside the dwelling unit?
Even if re-designated as a 13R? I doubt it.

On 10/23/07, Chris Cahill <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Clearly, you have asked a question about a murky issue.  How do you like
> that it's clearly murky?  I guess it's scale/size.  13R closets are
> typically, what, 4' x 8' on the large size.  In theory, I guess they could
> be any size. I'm not trying to be difficult, it just comes naturally.
>
> Perhaps you mentioned the size earlier. I have in me brain a 500-1000 sq.
> ft. basement.  In a traditional apt. you'd never have a closet that big.  OK
> let's leave the high end condo's out of this.
>
> As far as 13R and what defines outside I'd say what defines inside.  The
> definition in 3.3.4 doesn't mention storage or mechanical as part of the
> dwelling unit.  We all acknowledge there are closets in an apartment.  What
> limits I don't know.  But see above on what is only my opinion.  Clearly
> there is a hole in the definitions or scopes.  Committee proposal anyone
> (public proposal are closed)?
>
> As far as your row house, rated or not it's better defined from the
> separations what is in a unit. And there is usually the assumption or option
> they would convert a basement into a living space except for the
> mechanicals.
>
> And for what it's worth in a past life I'd probably have allowed it at .05
> as AHJ calling it part of the dwelling unit.  But then again the adopting
> authority hasn't messed this issue up here.  It would be 13D from the start
> and then we don't have these issues.  Now as a contractor I'm swayed on the
> conservative side of things.  It may sound hypocritical but life is a gray
> area with a dashed wavy line running through it.
>
> A note, I'm in MN, there are no Guido's or Stumpy's and our cold reputation
> would rule out a day trip for them to take care of business.  Hell, they'd
> first have to find it on a map.  This is flyover land.  Now if they have
> friends in the Norwegian Mafia I'd be afraid of Sven and Ole.  But most MN's
> are rather introverted so the worst I'd get is they'd look at my shoes.  A
> little local humor for all you southerners.  Wonder what the NSA computers
> are doing with all this talk of Guido's and Mafia's.  I think I see a SWAT
> van coming up the road.
>
> Chris
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of George Church
> Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 10:06 AM
> To: [email protected]
> Subject: RE: in or outside dwelling unit?
>
> What part of 13R deems the basement outside the Dwelling Unit?
>
> The Tenant Storage I traditionally see is COMMON AREA outside the Dwelling
> Unit. My position is that the basement in this building is WITHIN the 13R
> definition of a dwelling unit, absent any guidance of why it is not. It is
> all one apartment.
>
> If this were a row of 3 bedroom condos (with individual basements)
> stretching across a city block, but without the necessary fire separations,
> would you be prescribing OH1 for the basements within each condo?
>
> What part of 13R deems the basement outside the Dwelling Unit?
>
> glc
>
> _______________________________________________
> Sprinklerforum mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
>
> To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
>


-- 
Ron Greenman
at home....
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to