George.. Et al (Did I get that right Ron?)

 
>From the commentary in '02


"For the purposes of NFPA 13R, a dwelling unit, which is defined in 3.3.3,
includes hotel and motel rooms and suites, dormitory rooms, apartments,
condominiums, sleeping rooms and most common areas in board and care
facilities, and similar living units. {{In general, a dwelling unit consists
of any part of a structure that is normally occupied and has a fuel loading
that is indicative of a residential environment.)) A dwelling unit also
includes the corridor that leads to the guest rooms in a hotel or motel type
facility"

Parentheses mine.

R/

Matt



Matthew J. Willis
Living Water Fire Protection, LLC.
1160 McKenzie Rd.
PO Box 877
Cantonment, FL. 32533
850-937-1850 Voice
850-937-1852 Facsimile
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 

----- >-----Original Message-----
----- >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
----- >[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On 
----- >Behalf Of George Church
----- >Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 11:43 AM
----- >To: [email protected]
----- >Subject: RE: in or outside dwelling unit?
----- >
----- >That's Stubby, your honor....
----- >
----- >My contention is that it doesn't matter if there are 
----- >open wood joists in the basement, doesn't matter if it's 
----- >the Music Room or the oval Office- 13R dwelling unit 
----- >definition, from my reading, includes this area.
----- >
----- >I don't recall anyone writing in that: 
----- >"people are living in an apt temporarily while their new 
----- >home is being finished, they sold the first home quicker 
----- >than they thought. They intend to store their goods in 
----- >the dining room from floor to ceiling for four months. 
----- >Does this mean when I read #13R the dining room needs to 
----- >be protected as #13 OH even tho its within the dwelling 
----- >unit that says up to 4 heads at .005?"
----- >
----- >Well, that'd be great FP, but it would exceed the 
----- >requirements of #13R, and I only want to fulfill them. 
----- >So if the Basement of this single apartment is part of 
----- >the dwelling unit- and I have yet to see a response 
----- >based in 13R that it isn't- then it doesn't matter if 
----- >the Montana Militia has M16 and DB7s stored in their 
----- >dwelling unit, it's a dwelling unit.
----- >
----- >Heck, its not even a big standard, you can page thru it 
----- >like the #13 of yore. And there's no reason to apply 
----- >anything from 13D to this 13R protection level :)
----- >
----- >FYI, except for the more expensive pump and a supply 
----- >duration I'd like to see at 20 minutes if the FD can be 
----- >there in 10~15 worst case, I only have a 2-head flow 
----- >elsewhere in these buildings so it's a 13D on steroids 
----- >with a reliable pump and controller. Under 13R we can 
----- >install 8" lintels and the basement's a 2-head calc, 
----- >too, all compliant-
----- >
----- >Unless someone can see where the dwelling unit stops 
----- >short of the door in the kitchen leading to the dreaded basement.
----- >
----- >glc
----- >
----- >-----Original Message-----
----- >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
----- >[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On 
----- >Behalf Of Roland Huggins
----- >Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 12:25 PM
----- >To: [email protected]
----- >Subject: Re: in or outside dwelling unit?
----- >
----- >Thats why I asked WHAT it was being used for and about 
----- >the ceiling to make sure it wasn't open joist (wouldn't 
----- >want to apply the 13D allowance to ignore joists in the 
----- >basement).
----- >
----- >Chris - you can disagree with me just don't answer the 
----- >door when Guido and his associate Stumpy are knocking lol.
----- >
----- >Roland
----- >
----- >On Oct 23, 2007, at 8:06 AM, George Church wrote:
----- >
----- >> What part of 13R deems the basement outside the Dwelling Unit?
----- >>
----- >> The Tenant Storage I traditionally see is COMMON AREA 
----- >outside the 
----- >> Dwelling Unit. My position is that the basement in 
----- >this building is 
----- >> WITHIN the 13R definition of a dwelling unit, absent 
----- >any guidance of 
----- >> why it is not. It is all one apartment.
----- >>
----- >> If this were a row of 3 bedroom condos (with 
----- >individual basements) 
----- >> stretching across a city block, but without the necessary fire 
----- >> separations, would you be prescribing OH1 for the 
----- >basements within 
----- >> each condo?
----- >>
----- >> What part of 13R deems the basement outside the Dwelling Unit?
----- >>
----- >> glc
----- >
----- >_______________________________________________
----- >Sprinklerforum mailing list
----- >[email protected]
----- >http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
----- >
----- >To Unsubscribe, send an email 
----- >to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
----- >(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
----- >
----- >_______________________________________________
----- >Sprinklerforum mailing list
----- >[email protected]
----- >http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
----- >
----- >To Unsubscribe, send an email 
----- >to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
----- >(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to