Steam tests yesterday and today, and it looks like the fundamental 
problem is that the engine cannot clear itself of condensate at slower 
speeds. Only when the engine speed is very high is there enough steam 
flow, and heating of the engine, to keep the engine clear. But then the 
boiler's steaming rate cannot keep up.

I cut away the gasketing in the way of the distribution block steam 
channels as Tony suggested, but there was no noticeable improvement. 
Then I got some fresh SLX alcohol, and tried again. Runs were a little 
longer, 20 seconds or so. Still the steam consumption was too much for 
the boiler.

Today I removed the exhaust pipe, as Tony suggested as an experiment, 
and increased the boiler heating by supplementing the alcohol burner 
with a butane torch. Exhaust pipe removal had no benefit. (Engine 
exhaust note just became a rude-sounding buzz.) The butane torch 
allowed running under steam to be continuous, but only at very high 
speed and with the safety lifting continuously. Of course the speed was 
too high for typically desired sub-escape velocity train operation, and 
the boiler would go dry within ten minutes.

Where to go now? Not sure, but I've learned a lot. Not sure that I want 
to enlarge the cylinder ports so that the cylinders have a longer 
portion of their cycle to clear themselves.

The whole project was an experiment to make a two-truck geared 
locomotive. That part worked. The pairing of the Jane cylinders with 
the Jane boiler was a calculated risk. Unfortunately the lack of close 
proximity between the cylinders & reverser and the 
boiler/burner/smokebox upset the original Jane's balance between 
steaming capability and steam requirement.

I don't think it's worth trying to make small improvements to the 
existing boiler assembly to try to increase the steaming rate. I think 
that the vertical engine configuration needs a larger supply of steam 
(not necessarily higher pressure) and an enclosure around it to allow 
it to warm up. 

The vertical engine configuration has too much cooling surface area, 
and only one source of heat (the steam) compared to when the cylinders 
are mounted horizontally next to the smoke box. The current boiler 
would probably be just fine for a much smaller vertical free-standing 
engine. I intend to try the boiler with two smaller engines, and then 
I'm going to compare their respective masses to the mass of the 
Jane-cylinder vertical. Maybe there's a correlation to be discovered 
between the engine's mass (that needs to be heated to operating 
temperature) and the calculated steaming capability of the boiler (per 
K.N.Harris).

Anyway, I'm grateful that I've dawdled so much over building that 
coal-fired boiler that I've talked about. This last exercise, and the 
previous one (also steaming problems) were well worth experiencing 
before diving in to a coal boiler. No hurray. As I understand it, the 
shelf life of my stock-piled coal is pretty long. Longer than for 
meths.

Steve


__________________________________________________________________
Switch to Netscape Internet Service.
As low as $9.95 a month -- Sign up today at http://isp.netscape.com/register

Netscape. Just the Net You Need.

New! Netscape Toolbar for Internet Explorer
Search from anywhere on the Web and block those annoying pop-ups.
Download now at http://channels.netscape.com/ns/search/install.jsp
_______________________________________________
SSLiveSteam mailing list
Send messages: [email protected]
Cancel subscription: http://postfix.45mm.com/mailman/listinfo/sslivesteam
Rules: http://www.45mm.com/sslivesteam_guide.html

Reply via email to