Hmmmmmmmm...
> Steam tests yesterday and today, and it looks like the fundamental
> problem is that the engine cannot clear itself of condensate at slower
> speeds. Only when the engine speed is very high is there enough steam
> flow, and heating of the engine, to keep the engine clear. But then the
> boiler's steaming rate cannot keep up.

Here are a few of my thoughts and things I have found about steam production 
and wobblers...

Firstly steam production of boilers...

The Jane arrangement of boiler is similar to the mamod in a lot of respects 
but has all the benifits and non of the drwabacks of the soft soldered 
Mamod. The fire box arrangement was/has been explored by Jack Welden and 
there are many old articles that Jack did on getting the most BTU's from a 
pot boiler....side sielding is one thing but you need to have the correct 
flow of the hot gasses and flme wrap aropund the boiler. The Mamod fire box 
is as close as you can get to the perfect dimensions for a 1.5" boiler...IP 
ahve reproduced those dimentions and have come up with a winner for the 
Jane.

Although Mamod was a toy...with the silly 12lb saefty valve for the pressure 
steam restriction that has been put on toy steam engines...the design was 
very carefully thought out and was way ahead for its time.

IP have the fire box as a replacement part and if one is serious about good 
steam production you can't go far wrong.

With the IP silver soldered boiler you can run 40/50lbs of pressure with no 
problem...but you need the BTU's...in the IP/Mamod?Jack Welden fire box that 
is very easily attained.

Which brings me to some other thoughts...I have made Tram/Backwoods style 
locos with the IP boiler and firebox.

What has and is the problem with using the IP or any anyother Mamod style 
double acting cylinders running fast is that you waste a lot of steam.

...let me explain...IP/Mamod cylinders are designed to be directly coupled 
to the wheels or if geared no higher than a 3 to 1 ratio...My Mamod and IP 
powered locos trundel around my system at about 15/20 scale MPH that works 
out to about 120RPM or two revolutions per second...and the boiler can keep 
up...I have a steam tram I made with a gearing of 4 to one with a pair of IP 
double acting cylinders and it is allways working in a steam deficiate 
position that is the cylinders are being asked to preform at 15/20 scale MPH 
and therefore rotating at close to 500 RPM...if you figger out the swept 
volume of the cylinders at that speed you will quicly see the amount of 
steam production needed to keep up that speed and really for no reason!!!

...yes for no reason...'cause I have a single cylinder old Mamod cylinder 
that I hav converted to single action...that is 1 power stroke to revolution 
that will pull a 1o car paasenger train with an all up weight of 20 lbs 
around my yard up and down hill no problem...Light engine full speed is 12 
scale MPH and pulling the 20 lbs of rolling stock it runs at a sedate 9 
scaleMPH.

...In other words you do not need 2 twin acting wobblers to get the job 
done...yes they are self starting if you are using RC but the Single double 
acting wobbler will self start as well 9 times out of ten if it does not 
stop at TDC. But runnimg at 9 Scale MPH you do not need RC.

I have a friend with a mountainous line here in Victoria and he runs the 
Roundhouse products with RC cause they would not make it 1/2 way round his 
system without it...I come over with my single acting wobbler and take the 
same train over his system for 40 minutes without touching it and we both 
sit back with a brew and enjoy the scene!

This is a bit of a ramble cause I think there is still something not 
right...I need you give me some more information case there is lots more 
things that can be going wrong.

1.   from cold how long does the boiler take to come up to blowing 
off...that is with a boiler just kissing the top of the gauge...or 3/4" down 
from full.

2.  do you have any ides at what the boiler is blowing off at?   The low 
pressure Mamod valve blows off at 12psi...and the problem with low pressure 
steam is that it condeses very quickly in a long run of line

3. placing the displacement luber right close to the boiler is best...I have 
all my lubers right after the steam control valve then the steam line goes 
back under the boiler for some super heat...VERY IMPORTANT!!!!

4. By pass the lubricator run a fress line from the steam control valve 
trought the boiler flames to the steam motor...this will help get rid of the 
condensate.



...Try that for now...need to know how those mods work first before we start 
to get really serious.

...allways having fun...Tony


>
> I cut away the gasketing in the way of the distribution block steam
> channels as Tony suggested, but there was no noticeable improvement.
> Then I got some fresh SLX alcohol, and tried again. Runs were a little
> longer, 20 seconds or so. Still the steam consumption was too much for
> the boiler.
>
> Today I removed the exhaust pipe, as Tony suggested as an experiment,
> and increased the boiler heating by supplementing the alcohol burner
> with a butane torch. Exhaust pipe removal had no benefit. (Engine
> exhaust note just became a rude-sounding buzz.) The butane torch
> allowed running under steam to be continuous, but only at very high
> speed and with the safety lifting continuously. Of course the speed was
> too high for typically desired sub-escape velocity train operation, and
> the boiler would go dry within ten minutes.
>
> Where to go now? Not sure, but I've learned a lot. Not sure that I want
> to enlarge the cylinder ports so that the cylinders have a longer
> portion of their cycle to clear themselves.
>
> The whole project was an experiment to make a two-truck geared
> locomotive. That part worked. The pairing of the Jane cylinders with
> the Jane boiler was a calculated risk. Unfortunately the lack of close
> proximity between the cylinders & reverser and the
> boiler/burner/smokebox upset the original Jane's balance between
> steaming capability and steam requirement.
>
> I don't think it's worth trying to make small improvements to the
> existing boiler assembly to try to increase the steaming rate. I think
> that the vertical engine configuration needs a larger supply of steam
> (not necessarily higher pressure) and an enclosure around it to allow
> it to warm up.
>
> The vertical engine configuration has too much cooling surface area,
> and only one source of heat (the steam) compared to when the cylinders
> are mounted horizontally next to the smoke box. The current boiler
> would probably be just fine for a much smaller vertical free-standing
> engine. I intend to try the boiler with two smaller engines, and then
> I'm going to compare their respective masses to the mass of the
> Jane-cylinder vertical. Maybe there's a correlation to be discovered
> between the engine's mass (that needs to be heated to operating
> temperature) and the calculated steaming capability of the boiler (per
> K.N.Harris).
>
> Anyway, I'm grateful that I've dawdled so much over building that
> coal-fired boiler that I've talked about. This last exercise, and the
> previous one (also steaming problems) were well worth experiencing
> before diving in to a coal boiler. No hurray. As I understand it, the
> shelf life of my stock-piled coal is pretty long. Longer than for
> meths.
>
> Steve
>
>
> __________________________________________________________________
> Switch to Netscape Internet Service.
> As low as $9.95 a month -- Sign up today at 
> http://isp.netscape.com/register
>
> Netscape. Just the Net You Need.
>
> New! Netscape Toolbar for Internet Explorer
> Search from anywhere on the Web and block those annoying pop-ups.
> Download now at http://channels.netscape.com/ns/search/install.jsp
> _______________________________________________
> SSLiveSteam mailing list
> Send messages: [email protected]
> Cancel subscription: http://postfix.45mm.com/mailman/listinfo/sslivesteam
> Rules: http://www.45mm.com/sslivesteam_guide.html
>
> 


_______________________________________________
SSLiveSteam mailing list
Send messages: [email protected]
Cancel subscription: http://postfix.45mm.com/mailman/listinfo/sslivesteam
Rules: http://www.45mm.com/sslivesteam_guide.html

Reply via email to