At 08:33 PM 11/29/06 -0500, you wrote:
>Next question - what silver solder alloys are preferred for our small scale
>boilers, and why?
Casey,
There are 100's of alloys and like a lot of things these days most of
them are highly specialized and developed for a special purpose. However
one of the most common and widely used general purpose silver-solders is
45% silver non-cadmium bearing solder and it is excellent in every way for
copper boilers of all sizes. One of the brand names is Harris Safety-Silv
45 but all the major solder mfgs make an equivalent
You can get solders with more or less silver content but more silver
doesn't noticeably improve it's behavior or strength, and less silver can
affect the "fluidity" at liquid temperature which is important to us for
good joint penetration. Strength is not really as issue as the tensil
strength of most silver solders is almost double that of copper so a sound
joint is stronger than the parent metal.
Cadmium bearing solder is still available, and cadmiun noticeably
improves the wetting and flow behavior of the solder (a good thing) but
cadmium fumes are toxic and can really mess up your lungs. This can be
avoided if plenty of ventilation is provided but it's still a potential
problem and cad-bearing solders usually can't be found in stock at local
dealers any more.
Some people will instruct that you need two solders with different
melting points in order to do a boiler, so that previously soldered
assemblies won't melt when doing later heats. I'm not going to say you
won't on more comlex boilers, but for small scale work I think most people
can make do with a single solder.
>Are there silver solders that promote or retard the dezincification of brass?
No, at least none where a connection has been found . . . but don't use
brass in your boiler and you won't have to worry about it!
>that are too brittle for our purposes? . . . or that are unsuitable for
any of a number of reasons?
The "phos-coppers" (brand names Silfos, Phoson, etc) are brazing alloys
which contain from 0% to 15% silver and are meant for plumbing and
refrigeration work. For a time in the 1960s-70s quite a few copper boilers
were built with phos-copper because it was promoted by some as equal to
silver solder ("aww, it's the same stuff") but easier to find and costing
less, and it didn't require flux when joining copper to copper. It also
does not "flow" but builds up in thick fillets and can leave a flanged
joint completely dry (solderless) and you won't know it, until maybe it's
too late. Subsequent experience showed that phos-copper was a poor boiler
solder, in part due to brittleness and susceptability to weakening in
sulphuruous atmospheres (ie, coal smoke!)
Regards,
Harry Wade
Nashville Tennessee
_______________________________________________
SSLiveSteam mailing list
Send messages: [email protected]
Cancel subscription: http://postfix.45mm.com/mailman/listinfo/sslivesteam
Rules: http://www.45mm.com/sslivesteam_guide.html