Ah, I see what you are talking about. How about this: - Add a set-property to the plugin like <set-property property="use-suffix" value=".foo" /> - If present, only paths that end in the specified suffix will be forwarded to Cocoon first, and all others handled by Struts normally. - If not present, pass every request to Cocoon first.
Good idea. It looks like I better fire up a real project and all its trappings. Again, thanks for the good feedback and ideas. Don On 7 Mar 2003, Dave Patton wrote: > Yes. That was the idea was to modify the plugin so you can specify > either Struts or Cocoon as the front end. If it is Struts, then just > route all *.(whatever) requests to Cocoon. If Cocoon is first then > proceed as you have it now? What do you think? > > Dave Patton > > > On Fri, 2003-03-07 at 10:42, Don Brown wrote: > > > Exactly. When performance is key, you can have Struts use JSP directly. > > Of course, with how the plugin is now, the request will still be sent to > > Cocoon which would reject it. As for the processing time it takes for > > Cocoon to reject it, I don't know. My guess is it would depend on whether > > Cocoon was using compiled sitemaps or not. > > > > Again, of course you could rewrite the plugin so it only processes > > requests ending with "coc", but then you couldn't wrap existing struts > > applications without modifying all the forwards in struts-config.xml. > > > > Don > > > > On 7 Mar 2003, Dave Patton wrote: > > > > > But if performance is a concern, shouldnt I user Struts as the front end > > > and then provide a mapping for all *.xml (or whatever other pattern I > > > use) requests to the cocoon servlets? This way I only incur the cocoon > > > performance penalty on those requests which absolutely require cocoon? > > > Im sure there are more ways to skin this cat. > > > > > > Dave Patton > > > > > > On Fri, 2003-03-07 at 01:36, ROSSEL Olivier wrote: > > > > > > > > There are at least two ways to handle the forwards: > > > > > explicitly using some > > > > > sort of suffix/prefix (e.g. all paths that end in ".coc" will > > > > > be handled > > > > > by the cocoon plugin) or simply pass all the request first to > > > > > cocoon and > > > > > if cocoon doesn't handle it, process it normally. The stxx plugin > > > > > (http://sf.net/projects/stxx) uses the former while I chose > > > > > the latter. > > > > > In my implementation, if you don't create a pipeline to match > > > > > the forward, > > > > > it is processed by Struts normally. It is trival to write code to use > > > > > either method. > > > > > > > > > > Hope that helps. > > > > > > > > Cocoon has an impressive URl management system (for example, it can trigger > > > > not on the URL but on some combination of request parameters if you want :-) > > > > So Cocoon as the front-end is the best, IMHO. > > > > > > > > This e-mail is intended only for the above addressee. It may contain > > > > privileged information. If you are not the addressee you must not copy, > > > > distribute, disclose or use any of the information in it. If you have > > > > received it in error please delete it and immediately notify the sender. > > > > Security Notice: all e-mail, sent to or from this address, may be > > > > accessed by someone other than the recipient, for system management and > > > > security reasons. This access is controlled under Regulation of > > > > Investigatory Powers Act 2000, Lawful Business Practises. > > > > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > > > > > > > > > > _________________________________ > > > David H. Patton > > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > (202) 276-8998 - pcs > > > > > > -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > > > > > > Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use <http://www.pgp.com> > > > > > > mQENBDui6osBCADP9OqVftQ2qxZz2fsxEf6GT6V2Fu0c2iIIMeWGyc5Pwl+xXe2w > > > 3wx2pmNkLy3Zjp2/5q4nhvJd/GVn5gRR9OVTKgAz4o+xcOcAVIbgz3xFICbLozKa > > > 2aZOUDtOu0TuYGhI9iIeGuPjnMjsS38EfZQ2DWwd+p5UW6wnsSuG7xniUT372v8w > > > YrtUwnKQwjRUGUlZoX1zwvJj50xEzipyyHosMuzjoHme+d+MEECRhAK81p0487kl > > > X0UMXBehnsFK1mjbtQgfy2fdk0KT4NxKSD5s8ojoSdJ7R5CMwvh1UM4v2aAEqKvE > > > CYaCWrAfZ7+TQGHXu75ejJz1iIuUno1fVsgLABEBAAG0IkRhdmUgUGF0dG9uIDxk > > > cGF0dG9uQG52ZW50dXJlLmNvbT6JAS4EEAECABgFAjui6osICwMJCAcCAQoCGQEF > > > GwMAAAAACgkQ5ZDkPqeKwH9Xswf/aP2WGiAU+HFxV136uKW5oDtZtSvm0YuW69Ra > > > A2dPKFPp6E7v+w2c7yEV4+ZkVxbfk+VOh3p1MpXR367nQl9C+jMAD7MvPU6/KI+T > > > 5WDzzKEGsyxOI+GYeGRKO0ZAYITG9HxevvKa1GMHBwRYNr2Qv62ckkHTy5rdmzZe > > > PFM/am8B9maH5gKg6oIqzJwfmvb+ll8DRbhfI25trLqzggifrFcZHkOwTVGLNfdM > > > cPWK/Yu4dOLAKCow06q0G/tDmXNkcyx12R6Z4Y/cQ5Qyvt1WP+eQAM/HBJI8rR9c > > > cxS80pEorJIx4a7x9EsiwmB8milqBrXqHN2GRe/PnZSM9czBK7kBDQQ7ouqNAQgA > > > sWO4lchFwK6leJClCpdaCjL4oUGjiZorW+XG2YKtQW6a+oYlplcHFkMSibkTN6Jc > > > RdPEkarRvJ7sj+UgsUfkj4//EtqARuHTXhnMlsjqISTXlS2l61fQFg1d0iwvinyV > > > sq6lVDtrr7UBe2b5TOuoRe13CzGWyhNQafV1gMcpBx9KxNi24UowJiT+cJpnxMCu > > > +DNElC2AmG7phPagSFL8F4f++dGL2l8kAkxCSCl3Kr+8HUlFmOwwZ1PGSSM83pM/ > > > NNZKDAdGUiBRKqC32oOhKacxb6cf4ta1kZ6GDZcqVo+5qlz4OtUKbRLtW5Y8tiFc > > > PwkDePX/F1490V3YWgHVzwARAQABiQEiBBgBAgAMBQI7ouqNBRsMAAAAAAoJEOWQ > > > 5D6nisB/8xsIAJLNUQC8SOQF5txBrO22W7uAJ9xU9RK66Pyf9a+KjdNf4rE6vK4n > > > vhbSGmtoPB4bzOQ9RKpo8ihBQp1cY9mLnwuJDKSuzpkaOK5pd+bifwY20tweULR6 > > > 4rtU8uLL1H0eom2IBjSXhf4n8DEdyrGKKHYNO/GRLx/UHHcLEFvz+4buHrCPoiBP > > > JwjS/Ifg5xc3nTJnZmG2HzapoRwgXxGitbNTArUZWkqHYLygA1/ilmnFs8POj/s+ > > > TD4wSuDlrwE2CE2O8XbRuRVPryzn8mXXdZ1pSwrrvZjRU5rnDRAOqhHZQQbudVd3 > > > XvnDDBDoURSqwDqnwOkoOSTC95aj+vy5WW0= > > > =/zoc > > > > > > -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > > > > > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > > _________________________________ > David H. Patton > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > (202) 276-8998 - pcs > > -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > > Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use <http://www.pgp.com> > > mQENBDui6osBCADP9OqVftQ2qxZz2fsxEf6GT6V2Fu0c2iIIMeWGyc5Pwl+xXe2w > 3wx2pmNkLy3Zjp2/5q4nhvJd/GVn5gRR9OVTKgAz4o+xcOcAVIbgz3xFICbLozKa > 2aZOUDtOu0TuYGhI9iIeGuPjnMjsS38EfZQ2DWwd+p5UW6wnsSuG7xniUT372v8w > YrtUwnKQwjRUGUlZoX1zwvJj50xEzipyyHosMuzjoHme+d+MEECRhAK81p0487kl > X0UMXBehnsFK1mjbtQgfy2fdk0KT4NxKSD5s8ojoSdJ7R5CMwvh1UM4v2aAEqKvE > CYaCWrAfZ7+TQGHXu75ejJz1iIuUno1fVsgLABEBAAG0IkRhdmUgUGF0dG9uIDxk > cGF0dG9uQG52ZW50dXJlLmNvbT6JAS4EEAECABgFAjui6osICwMJCAcCAQoCGQEF > GwMAAAAACgkQ5ZDkPqeKwH9Xswf/aP2WGiAU+HFxV136uKW5oDtZtSvm0YuW69Ra > A2dPKFPp6E7v+w2c7yEV4+ZkVxbfk+VOh3p1MpXR367nQl9C+jMAD7MvPU6/KI+T > 5WDzzKEGsyxOI+GYeGRKO0ZAYITG9HxevvKa1GMHBwRYNr2Qv62ckkHTy5rdmzZe > PFM/am8B9maH5gKg6oIqzJwfmvb+ll8DRbhfI25trLqzggifrFcZHkOwTVGLNfdM > cPWK/Yu4dOLAKCow06q0G/tDmXNkcyx12R6Z4Y/cQ5Qyvt1WP+eQAM/HBJI8rR9c > cxS80pEorJIx4a7x9EsiwmB8milqBrXqHN2GRe/PnZSM9czBK7kBDQQ7ouqNAQgA > sWO4lchFwK6leJClCpdaCjL4oUGjiZorW+XG2YKtQW6a+oYlplcHFkMSibkTN6Jc > RdPEkarRvJ7sj+UgsUfkj4//EtqARuHTXhnMlsjqISTXlS2l61fQFg1d0iwvinyV > sq6lVDtrr7UBe2b5TOuoRe13CzGWyhNQafV1gMcpBx9KxNi24UowJiT+cJpnxMCu > +DNElC2AmG7phPagSFL8F4f++dGL2l8kAkxCSCl3Kr+8HUlFmOwwZ1PGSSM83pM/ > NNZKDAdGUiBRKqC32oOhKacxb6cf4ta1kZ6GDZcqVo+5qlz4OtUKbRLtW5Y8tiFc > PwkDePX/F1490V3YWgHVzwARAQABiQEiBBgBAgAMBQI7ouqNBRsMAAAAAAoJEOWQ > 5D6nisB/8xsIAJLNUQC8SOQF5txBrO22W7uAJ9xU9RK66Pyf9a+KjdNf4rE6vK4n > vhbSGmtoPB4bzOQ9RKpo8ihBQp1cY9mLnwuJDKSuzpkaOK5pd+bifwY20tweULR6 > 4rtU8uLL1H0eom2IBjSXhf4n8DEdyrGKKHYNO/GRLx/UHHcLEFvz+4buHrCPoiBP > JwjS/Ifg5xc3nTJnZmG2HzapoRwgXxGitbNTArUZWkqHYLygA1/ilmnFs8POj/s+ > TD4wSuDlrwE2CE2O8XbRuRVPryzn8mXXdZ1pSwrrvZjRU5rnDRAOqhHZQQbudVd3 > XvnDDBDoURSqwDqnwOkoOSTC95aj+vy5WW0= > =/zoc > > -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
