Warning voices over the expansion of biofuels Is the expansion of biofuels a beneficial regional and national model? There are those who believe otherwise. In Argentina, the Grupo de Reflexion Rural (GRR) have warned of the effects of the present madness for biofuels. GRR members Jorge E. Rulli and Stella Semino have systematically set out their position on this issue through a number of articles. According to them, this situation equates to another turn of the screw by the colonial model whose sole aim is to create an economic supremacy based on the export of agricultural commodities and the plunder of our resources. Rulli and Semino point out that the intensification of a rural model which is bound to the interests of the global agri-business, is a model which has already turned Argentina into a 'soya republic' to the benefit of the multinational corporations dedicated to the production and sale of genetically modified seeds. 'At the present time', they remind us, 'Argentina has pledged its fertile lands to a monoculture whose sole purpose is to provide forage for intensively reared cattle and poultry in wealthy countries. But now, we have to make room for the massive production of biodiesel and ethanol needed by Europe and the United States to mix with their gasoline. The principal objective of the biofuels industry is to provide exports to rich countries, and this exacerbates the struggle for land (bioenergy versus production of agricultural goods). GRR predict that this will bring about a rise in food prices in Argentina and the rest of the world. The authors believe that 'the current changes in the use of agricultural lands, used previously for the production of forage or food, and now being increasingly used for the production of compounds for agro-energy. Will undoubtedly place at risk the sovereign rights of our citizens to healthy nutrition'. This will occur in a country which has not yet been able to heal the scars left by hunger. Statistics indicate that in Argentina there are 260,000 malnourished children under 5 years of age. According to the National Survey of Nutrition and Health which was carried out in December there is a malnourished child for every 153 Argentinians. 'Soya is not just a crop. It is a system. Soya is the general system which places conditions on any policy', the GRR members reiterate as they explain the characteristics of the current agrarian model. They add: 'People's security and food sovereignty disappear in the catastrophic framework that accompanies the soya: through the creation of a consumption-dependence cycle, the uprooting and displacement of rural communities, hunger, poverty and environmental collapse' 'This model is not only unsustainable, but also poses a serious threat to agricultural systems and biodiversity. It is responsible for the eviction of rural communities and their displacement to towns. It destroys regional economies and rejects any application of agricultural sciences, favouring instead the sole use of agro-toxic chemicals and biotechnology,' allege Rulli and Semino. On the other hand, biofuels have achieved notoriety, even among environmentalists, as a 'carbon neutral' renewable source of energy, which therefore would produce no greenhouse gasses. Nevertheless, Dr Mae-Wan Ho, Professor of Biology, Open University and advisor on the biotechnology of genetic engineering and biological security, assures us that this is a myth. 'There exist realistic estimates', she states, 'that show that the generation of energy via crops requires more fossil fuel energy than the energy they yield, and that these do not substantially reduce the emission of greenhouse gasses when all factors are included in the calculations. Additionally, they cause damage to the soils and to the environment'. Semino also disputes the supposedly benign effects brought about by the use of biodiesel, for example, in terms of a reduction in carbon dioxide emissions. According to her analysis, the positive environmental balance sheet proclaimed in Argentina does not take account of the gases produced by changes in land use, the burning of scrub and forest to expand the land given over to growing soya, the nitrogenous fertilization which has taken place in recent years to increase soya yields; the 15 million hectares of residue vegetation left after the crop has been harvested. 'In the past few years, we have been against the land being used for the provision of forage and other commodities destined for international markets. We cannot allow vast expanses of land to be dedicated to agro-energy in the same way'. With the above objections in mind, there is one final question to ask of those who, in order to continue feeding today's global markets, promote agro-energy as a substitute for fossil fuels: Have they considered the risks of using agriculture, not only for food production, but for the production of energy as well? Marcelo Lorenzo, El Dia de Gualeguaychu. Sources: BiodiversidadLa, Grupo de Reflexión Rural (c) 2000-2007 www.pagina12.com.ar/República Argentina/All Rights Reserved
********************************************** -- Man is most nearly himself when he achieves the seriousness of a child at play. - Heraclitus _______________________________________________ RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for: [email protected] http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org
