Addressing Global Warming, Air Pollution Health Damage, and Long-Term Energy Needs Simultaneously
http://www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/ClimateHealth4.pdf By Mark Z. Jacobson Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering Stanford University http://www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/ May 9, 2006; Revised June 6, 2006 Summary below -- full article at the pdf link above. -- Martha Disclaimer: The author has no known financial interest in any of the energy technologies discussed in this report. Summary Proponents of ethanol suggest that it is a clean and renewable fuel that will reduce air pollution and address climate change. Data, computer model results, and new emission information suggest that ethanol is neither clean nor has it been shown that it can slow global warming. To the contrary, its promotion will continue the public health crisis that has resulted in thousands of premature air-pollution-related deaths and millions of cases of asthma and respiratory disease each year in the U.S. It will also divert resources from wind- and solar energy for electric power, for electric vehicles, and for electricity- derived-hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles, the only solutions to global warming and air pollution simultaneously for which sufficient original resources exist (solar and wind energy) to solve these problems entirely on their own. The main findings of this report are as follows: 1) Laboratory data and the first three-dimensional computer model simulations on the subject suggest that E85 fuel (85% ethanol and 15% gasoline) will increase atmospheric levels of ozone and peroxyacetyl nitrate (PAN), leading indicators of photochemical smog, in the Los Angeles basin, the most polluted airshed in the U.S. 2) E85 will increase two major carcinogens, acetaldehyde and formaldehyde while slightly reducing another, butadiene, and reducing a fourth, benzene. A combination of available emission and carcinogenicity data suggest an equally-probable disadvantage or advantage of E85 versus gasoline with respect to cancer risk. 3) Due to its similar cancer risk but the enhanced ozone and PAN formation resulting from its use, E85 can be concluded to be an equal or greater risk to public health than gasoline based on data to date. E85 will continue to contribute to the thousands of cases of premature mortality and millions of cases of asthma and respiratory disease in the U.S. that fossil-fuel vehicles currently cause. 4) Studies to date suggest little reduction or an exacerbation of global warming due to corn-ethanol versus gasoline as a fuel. All the studies, though, have not included most or all of seven additional sources of emission that enhance global warming, Page 2 2 suggesting that corn ethanol must cause more warming than all studies have estimated. 5) Cellulosic ethanol is a technology that has been around for over 15 years at the laboratory scale but still does not exist at the field scale. All studies of cellulosic ethanol have missed most or all the same emission sources as the corn-ethanol studies missed. Thus, all estimates of the effects of cellulosic ethanol on global warming to date are premature and low. 6) Wind and solar energy resources are sufficient to reduce both global warming and air pollution simultaneously. A recent world wind-mapping study suggests that sufficient wind power is available over land to satisfy all electric and vehicle power demand worldwide up to five times over. Solar power is more abundant than wind. Solar photovoltaics are more expensive than wind but easier to site. Solar thermal is both easy to site and inexpensive. 7) Fossil-fuel vehicles can be replaced, and their pollution eliminated, by electric vehicles, where the electricity is derived from wind or solar power, and by hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (HFCVs), where the hydrogen is derived from wind or solar power. In the latter case, hydrogen is obtained by using electricity from wind or solar to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. No pollution is emitted during this process or during the use of the HFCV, in which the chemical reaction is reversed (hydrogen plus oxygen producing water and energy). Although these technologies face hurdles (e.g., possible platinum shortages upon large penetration of HFCVs and setting up a fueling or charging infrastructure in both cases), the technologies work. Today, California has about 100 hydrogen vehicles and many electric vehicles on the road. Hydrogen electrolysis from wind is estimated from the literature to cost (conservatively) $1.12- $3.20 per equivalent gallon of gasoline. 8) Wind and solar together, if fully implemented, can eliminate millions of cases of asthma and respiratory disease and hundreds of thousands of deaths worldwide from air pollution each year and ultimately, can eliminate global warming. E85 from corn- ethanol, on the other hand is estimated to cost $0.30-$1.80/gallon due to its health and climate effects alone. This cost will also nearly be eliminated with wind- and solar- powered vehicles. 9) Given the certainty of ethanol's carcinogenicity and smog potential relative to wind and solar, the certainty of ethanol's higher carbon emissions than wind and solar, and the fact that neither wind nor solar resources, particularly in the U.S., have been exploited nearly to their potential, the promotion of ethanol (corn or cellulosic) at the expense of wind and solar would appear to be a poor policy decision in terms of the resulting effects on air pollution and climate. -- -------------------------------- Martha Armstrong 120 Homestead Circle Ithaca, NY 14850 607-277-2790 _______________________________________________ RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for: [email protected] http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org
