On Mon, Jan 7, 2013 at 11:58 AM, Andrew Thule <thules...@gmail.com> wrote: > > On Sun, Jan 6, 2013 at 11:12 AM, DM Smith <dmsm...@crosswire.org> wrote: > >> No, we cannot publish the terms of licensing agreements. Think about it. >> These are confidential, privileged contracts between organizations. > > > Umm, with software Licenses, Acceptable Use Policies, Copyright Restrictions > and Copyright limitations are not typically priviledge .. > > The contractual agreement itself may be, but License for use, especially in > public forums is not, otherwise how can you come down so hard on someone > like me for trying to abide by licensing agreement when those agreements are > not know? > > You're saying on the one had I have to abide by Crosswire's agreement with > the Copyright Owner and on the other hand I cannot know what those > provisions are.
False. We're saying you have to abide by Copyright laws. According to Copyright laws you have no claim on these modules unless there is either (1) no Copyright holder, as is the case for any modules in the public domain or (2) you have been granted permission by the Copyright holder. This could be in the case of content where the holder has publicly permitted anyone rights, otherwise you need to negotiate your own license with the Copyright holder if you want to distribute. You have no need to make your license public to anyone if you negotiate the rights to a module and neither does CrossWire. The only people who need to know the specific terms are CrossWire's point of contact (usually Troy or Chris but it could be whoever negotiated the contract) and the Copyright holder. Additionally a copy could be submitted to law enforcement or courts if legislation arose or the like. > For example, I am particularly disappointed that I was accused of breaking > Crosswire's licensing restrictions, yet no one has bothered to either > publically name one module that was available at my repo that should have > been, or provide access to Crosswire's license as evidence this was wrong. You don't need to see the specifics of CrossWire's license agreements. You just need to understand basic Copyright function. Is the text under Copyright? Do you have the permission of the Copyright holder to distribute the text? If the answer to the first question is "yes" and the answer to the second is "no" then you don't have the right to distribute the work. Regardless of who DOES have the right, you do not. And regardless of under which conditions they have the right, you do not. You don't need to know under what permissions CrossWire has the right to distribute a module publicly in electronic format anymore than you need to know what agreement Zondervan has to publish a paper copy. You also don't need to know what agreement Amazon has or Netflix has to electronically make available copies of movies to know that you do not have a right to mirror their content without permission from at least the Copyright holder. --Greg _______________________________________________ sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel@crosswire.org http://www.crosswire.org/mailman/listinfo/sword-devel Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page