2010/5/28 sylvain letuffe <li...@letuffe.org>: > So every "città" in Italy is tagged place=city ? So you can have a 1 to 1 > città<>city ? > > So all this are tagged place=city : > http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citt%C3%A0_dell%27Italia ? > > and this is just fud : > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-it/2010-May/015939.html
No, as Martin said perfectly. > and this : > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/IT:Key:place > > place=city: popolazione oltre i 100.000 abitanti, o capoluogo di regione, o > capoluogo di provincia e almeno 50.000 abitanti > + > l'unica città di una ampia area può essere classificata place=city anche se > ha 90.000 abitanti. Yes, this is what we (almost) agreed to do. > Ain't this just equivalent to constructing a list ? No. It would if we had said, "more than 100.000 PLUS Alessandria and Siena". We've tried to mediate between an "objective" criterion based on quantifiable and verifiable data and a "common sense" one based on the fact that "many feel this should be a city". Yet, again, we're not "feeling it should be a city" because we want it to appear on the map with a large font, but because we feel that, if someone was to compile a list of the cities in Italy, that centre should be in it. I know it may look like a very subtle difference, but I don't think it is. > Common, please, tag for the renderer, this is not a problem has it makes a > nice map in the end, but don't confuse me with a Bresaola... Whawhawhat?! > -- > sly > -- Regards, Simone _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
