I do see bakery (baked goods) and confectionery (candy, chocolates) and the shops that sell them as very different so would never use the later for any of the former. If I go to a telephone business book (yellow pages) or a book section in a book store, I expect bakery and baking books to cover breads, cakes, pastries, etc. Similarly if I use the business directory or bookstore section for confectionery, I expect a chocolate or candy store or books on chocolate or candy making. Here (Western US), i usually do not first think of a bakery shop for bread, but instead as one selling cakes, cookies, pastries, cupcakes, pies or a combination thereof and maybe breads. We tend to call shops where mainly bread is sold, bread stores; but I would still look under bakery in the business directory for one. Here confectionery shops are more likely to sell something like nuts or dried fruit with chocolates and/or candy than they are to sell pastries. The few that do mix candy and pastries are also likely to offer cakes, cupcakes, or cookies.
Rather than push for shop=pastry it makes more sense to change the text on the wiki to expand what bakery stands for (and remove pastries from the description of the confectionery). If you want more detail then perhaps the proposal should be: shop=bakery, cuisine=* where cuisine could be bread, cakes, wedding cakes, cupcakes, cookies, pastries, pies, or a list if one type is not predominant at the shop. This would nicely parallel amenity=cafe; cuisine=cake for places where you consume the product within the business (cafe) rather than take it from the business (shop). I suppose the debate then could become amenity=fast_food; cuisine=cookie versus shop=bakery; cuisine=cookie for the cookie counters in the shopping malls. :-) Murry
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging