On 26.09.2013 14:24, bredy wrote: As I have been traveling to two of the "biggest" falls on globe, I am interested in this discussion.
> Niagara Falls are tagged as area with tag waterway=waterfall + natural=cliff. Well it is tagged as site. The American Fall is tagged as waterway=waterfall as node in a way with natural=cliff plus an area with waterway=waterfall and natural=cliff, the Horseshoe Fall is tagged as node with waterway=waterfall and a way as cliff The Victory Falls are tagged similar to the Horseshoe Fall and not divided but should be. > For me waterway=waterfall is better for node or segment of waterway. Or with > key waterfall=yes > > And natural=waterfall is better for large river that use riverbank. Only for > way or area. Render as cliff but blue. +1 but they are called falls (natural=waterfalls ?). I am not sure if we can judge the definition by only looking at these big examples. Think about kajaks and white water sports. Major problem once more is documentation. cheers fly _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
