Thanks to all who have spilled much ink and provided extensive comment on this proposal[1] -- the feedback is deeply appreciated as it increases confidence that the proposal reflects community consensus. The hazard tag has attracted an additional 2,000 usages just over the course of this RFC, and given the attention that this has gotten, I want to make sure we get this right.
As currently written, this proposal: - Creates 5 new keys - Creates 28 new values on these new keys - Adds 2 new values to existing keys - Deprecates 19 tag values Given the scope and extent of the discussion and feedback, I am holding this RFC open past the 2-week minimum period in order to allow additional opportunity for community input. Below the cut line is a summary of the significant changes made to the proposal and decisions made through the course of this RFC. If there is additional input, please provide it! If anyone feels that they are a "no" vote for this proposal, I especially want to hear from you, as a vote should be confirmation of community consensus achieved through discussion. ==== Summary of Changes since the start of RFC ==== * Added: hazard=bump (signed natural bumps, not traffic_calming=*) hazard=frost_heave hazard=loose_gravel hazard=low_flying_aircraft hazard=horse_riders (equestrians in the roadway, not highway=crossing) hazard=pedestrians (pedestrians in the roadway, not highway=crossing) hazard=queues_likely hazard=slippery hazard=unexploded_ordnance * Changed: Add hazard=cyclists; deprecate hazard=bicycle, bicycles Add hazard=falling_rocks, landslide; deprecate rock_slide, rockfall * Removed from proposal (but not deprecated): hazard=yes hazard=school_crossing * Clarified that mappers should not tag subjective hazard features which cannot be confirmed or denied even when visiting the location in person. * Declined to add a "narrow road" hazard, as this is controversial based on a past proposal[2] to eliminate the width=narrow tag, and is deserving of its own proposal if a narrow road hazard is desired. [1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/hazard [2] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Narrow_width
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
