On Mon, Jan 25, 2010 at 3:53 PM, Liz <ed...@billiau.net> wrote: > > Great work Roy
Cheers :) > (not providing any suggestions) Alright how's this.... > > It is an advisory sign to all road users advising the street is not > > intended to be used by through traffic, however vehicles are the > > primary target (bicycles and pedestrians are generally not an issue)." Unfortunately, this response is still a little unclear. But I would read that "generally not an issue" here means "excluded". Please let me know if you disagree (in which case, you in fact aren't allowed to *walk* through a "Local Traffic Only" sign, and access=destination is the correct tag to use). So, if everyone agrees that response means bicycles/pedestrians are excluded, then from http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:access we could use: vehicle=destination (which - perhaps wrongly - includes bicycles), or motor_vehicle=destination (which - perhaps wrongly - excludes a horse and carriage). motor_vehicle=destination seems best to me. I'd propose, for tags in Queensland (and possibly elsewhere in AU): 1) a bulk change of access=destination to motor_vehicle=destination + FIXME="does access=destination really apply to bicycles/pedestrians here?" 2) an update to http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Australian_Tagging_Guidelines recommending the use of motor_vehicle=destination + motor_vehicle:source="Local Traffic Only sign" in these cases. I propose a bulk update because a) I can't think of any other reason why access=destination would be applied to ways in Queensland, other than due to the observance of "Local Traffic Only" sign, and b) this reportedly adversely affects foot routing, so it should be fixed. > > "The 'Local Traffic Only' sign is an advisory sign only and is not > > regulatory. I don't think this is important, but this could be specified using motor_vehicle:regulatory=no (or inferred from motor_vehicle:source="Local Traffic Only sign") Thoughts? _______________________________________________ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
