On 6/13/2016 5:55 PM, Andy Townsend wrote:
As a bit more background to this, see the changeset discussion
comments on https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/39809705 and
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/39812846 . I got a reply re
"football vs soccer", but not about any of the other questions raised
in there.
Football.
Ok. No dissension on sport=football to sport= soccer ... if I can
identify it from bing imagery.
Where I cannot identify it I am inclined to leave a fixme tag on it.
--------------------------------
As for the other things ...
Court/pitch separation.
For example way 422897831 ... from bing. There is a faint outline of
what to me is a netball court. So I added that.
I am inclined to separate individual sport courts .. so there is a
overlay of a tennis court there too.. Some courts are head to tail
aligned as here, others are, for example, 4 tennis courts and 3 netball
courts .. thus the individual mapping allows for visual identification
of this. Also some courts run across the other courts - one set north to
south the others east to west. I think the added detail is better than
numerical tags as these separate courts render without any additional
requirements, make it clear as to the number and orientation of the
courts. It is more work but easy to do and has some benefit.
Field_hockey.
Hummm yes well ... I am not familiar with soccer other than the 11 a
side one (which I played on many Saturdays in a club). I think some of
the 'smaller' games look to me very much like field hockey markings ? It
would help if there were tags to identify these ... for example
sport=soccer, soccer:5_a_side:yes, soccer:minisoccer=yes But I think
more urgent would be some documentation on the wiki (both soccer and
field_hockey)?
Sports on Recreation Grounds ...
I prefer to map the individual pitches as this gives the orientation,
location and number of pitches. While some of these may move from season
to season they don't usually move far due to size restrictions, nor do
the number of pitches change. I don't map 'social games' that have no on
ground infrastructure .. for example a game of football on a grassed
area I don't map it as a pitch... no sidelines, goal posts etc .. just
jumpers on the ground as markers for goals, corners ...
So putting sports on recreation grounds to me .. I don't do.
--------------------------
Future activity for me + sport?
Apart from sport=football there are sport=hockey (probably to
sport=field_hockey where identified by bing imagery) and sport=multi
(sport=x;multi where x is the sport identified by bing imagery) .. these
are all possibilities. The one with the most impact would be sport=multi
followed by sport=hockey.
_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
