Quote Key:highway: "It is a very general and sometimes vague description of the importance of the highway." (Was until last week:) " ... of the physical structure of the highway".
Either way, the highway tag itself should (IMO) convey they primary description of the highway - the distinction between two highway tags should be significant, not just a different sign if the allowed foot/cycle users are the same. For a cycling user (prove me wrong!) it's not important if the light traffic way where he may cycle is signed as "no motor vehicles" or "cycleway" or "combined cycle and footway". A router (yeah, it's not the only use for map data) may choose to prefer some type of those over others if they think there's some reasonable difference in expected travel speeds - but it's not the main attribute of the way. Given other tags are the same (at least surface, width, lit) they're all alike; for pedestrians too. If that user is on foot, it's even more so, if there's a foot=yes on the cycleways or if it is assumed default. There's a much bigger difference between ways planned and constructed for pedestrian and cycle traffic vs. the ways that have emerged from erosion caused by people walking that way. My point: I don't see a point in _not_ tagging ways such as these: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Image:Path-nomotortraffic.jpg and http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Image:Path-lighttraffic.jpg as cycleways with either foot=yes or foot=designated, respectively. -- Alv _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

