On 07/21/2012 01:31 AM, Hal Murray wrote:
(From a month ago.)
albertson.ch...@gmail.com said:
Take my word for it, the T-Bolt is not able to drive a 100 foot long twisted
pair cable
I don't think that's quite the right way to phrase it.
What type of twisted pair were you using and/or what sort of setup did you
try? How well did it work and/or what were you expecting?
Yes, you may get much better results if you use differential
drivers/receivers. But that's if you have common mode problems.
-----------
I remember, many years ago, when I got an interesting lesson in this area.
The difference between junk twisted pair and good stuff was impressive.
We were installing a T microwave link. On T1, a 1 is a pulse, a 0 is an
absence of a pulse during a bit slot. Pulses alternate polarity to keep a DC
balance. T1 is 1.544 megabits/second or 647 ns per bit. I don't remember
the details, but the ballpark is a 200 ns pulse has to get through. So the
rise time has to be in the ballpark of 20-50 ns.
We had to go a few hundred feet. My first try with a spool of whatever I
found in the lab was a joke. The spool of good stuff that we ordered worked
fine. I'm pretty sure the good-stuff was Belden Datalene but, again, it was
a long time ago and I don't remember any details. (I wonder if the cable is
still there.)
Does anybody have a good URL on lossy transmission lines? Is there any
obvious reason why twisted pairs should be different from coax?
Oh yes.
An archetypical coax has a conductor within another conductor. Their
magnetic and electrostatic coupling to the surrounding should be very
low. Real life is more complex.
An archetypical twisted pair has two conductors with insulator twisted
around each other. Only for lower frequencies will the twisting cancel out.
A shielded twisted pair combines some of these effects, but the
shielding cuts of at lower frequencies for magnetics, so the twisting
needs to handle that.
Maintaining properties in manufacturing and due to bending etc. is
certainly making a distinction. Use of insulator another.
There is an art in cable making.
There are several books on EMC and noise reduction techniques, which
gives some of the info. The book by Hendry Ott is a classic.
The PDH E1 and T1 signals attempts to get the most out of the cables,
and their waveshapes is fairly strictly controlled, as is the receiver
equalisation. One vendor had a bug in their chip, so they could only run
shorter distances than the datasheet said. They had a good stock of the
old revision and hid this fact, only after they had been lectured in the
lab and shown they didn't meet the spec, they came clean and gave us the
ordering details for the correct one... they had hid it pretty well,
since even the public ordering number of the part was the same, but the
internal ordering number was different.
Cheers,
Magnus
_______________________________________________
time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
and follow the instructions there.
