On 20/11/2014 20:53, Nicolas Évrard wrote: > * Cédric Krier [2014-11-20 19:38:06]: >> On 20 Nov 19:14, Pierre-Louis Bonicoli wrote: >>> On 20/11/2014 18:34, Nicolas Évrard wrote: >>>> I can understand that you want to spend all your time on your own >>>> projects (nereid, angular-tryton, www.tryton.us, etc) and in the >>>> overall they are good for Tryton. >>> >>> It seems not fair to call Nereid 'his own project'. >>> >>> At TUL2012 I asked why Nereid (a flask based web framework for tryton) >>> wasn't a part of the Tryton project. Nobody knew. After that Cédric >>> wrote a review of Nereid [1]. >>> >>> In mars 2013, Raimon Esteve asked on the tryton-contrib mailing list >>> about the inclusion of Nereid in Tryton. It appeared that: >>> - 2 minor bugs were still open (#31 #33) >>> - Cedric preferred to integrate a big amount of code at the beginning of >>> a development cycle >>> >>> Why hasn't Nereid been accepted yet ? >> >> Make search I have a lot of design issue with Nereid and I said that it >> can be replaced by few lines of code which I show later in flask-tryton. >> For me, it is clear that Nereid will not be part of Tryton and that we >> should focus on a better modular solution designed by the community as >> all other modules. > > In my opinion, Nereid should not be part of Tryton, but flask-tryton > should not either, and morepath-tryton neither and pyramid-tryton > neither. > > What should be part of tryton is reusable components that allow people > creating web interface on any of the aforementioned projects to start > with a good reusable basis and a good design. > > Just like we don't have all the variation of workflows on sale or > purchase, we should not have all the variations people are going to > use to access the Tryton server through an HTTP frontend.
It is a pity that you didn't answer this when Sharoon first asked [1], nor when you presented flask-tryton [2]. It gives the impression that you aren't willing to accept a big amount of code/work from others. [1] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/tryton-dev/VFnT8lX2lGE [2] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/tryton-dev/pk0FYIds2Sk -- Pierre-Louis
