Public bug reported:

It would be nice to remove gtk2 from tenacious. Debian is unable to
complete the removal of gtk2 because it is used in the Debian installer
and it is complicated for the installer to switch to gtk3 because vte
has switched to C++ in the new version. Since Ubuntu doesn't have that
problem, Ubuntu can proceed. I think it makes sense to file separate
bugs for different parts of the gtk2 removal, grouping where it makes
sense.

One app that is still maintained upstream and its packaging maintained
in Debian is gkrellm. Upstream hasn't yet switched away from gtk3 and
it's unclear how long it will take.

Please remove these packages. I have also attached g a merge request to
add them to the sync blocklist because they may still get Debian
uploads. If gkrellm is ported to gtk2, gkrellm and the plugins that are
compatible can sync to Ubuntu.

- gkrellm
- bfm
- gkrellkam
- gkrellm-leds
- gkrellm-mailwatch
- gkrellm-radio
- gkrellm-reminder
- gkrellm-tz
- gkrellm-volume
- gkrellmapcupsd
- gkrellmoon
- gkrellmwireless
- gkrellshoot
- gkrelltop
- gkrellweather

********
Analysis
********

https://transitions.ubuntu.com/html/gtk2-rm.html

$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm
Reverse-Depends
===============
* gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
* gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
* gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
* gkrelltopd                    (for gkrellmd)
* gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)

$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm
Reverse-Build-Depends
=====================
* bfm                           (for gkrellm)
* gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
* gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
* gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
* gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
* gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
* gkrelltop                     (for gkrellmd)
* gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)

$ reverse-depends -b src:bfm
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:bfm
Reverse-Recommends
==================
* junior-system                 (for bubblefishymon)
* junior-toys                   (for bubblefishymon)

$ reverse-depends src:gkrellkam
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellkam
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-leds
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-leds
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-mailwatch
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-mailwatch
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-radio
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-radio
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-reminder
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-reminder
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-tz
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-tz
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-volume
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-volume
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmapcupsd
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellmapcupsd
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellmoon
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmoon
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmwireless
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellmwireless
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellshoot
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellshoot
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrelltop
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrelltop
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends src:gkrellweather
No reverse dependencies found
$ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellweather
No reverse dependencies found

** Affects: gkrellm (Ubuntu)
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Affects: gkrellm (Debian)
     Importance: Unknown
         Status: Unknown


** Tags: gtk2-rm tenacious

** Description changed:

  It would be nice to remove gtk2 from tenacious. Debian is unable to
  complete the removal of gtk2 because it is used in the Debian installer
  and it is complicated for the installer to switch to gtk3 because vte
  has switched to C++ in the new version. Since Ubuntu doesn't have that
- problem, Ubuntu can proceed.
+ problem, Ubuntu can proceed. I think it makes sense to file separate
+ bugs for different parts of the gtk2 removal, grouping where it makes
+ sense.
  
  One app that is still maintained upstream and its packaging maintained
  in Debian is gkrellm. Upstream hasn't yet switched away from gtk3 and
  it's unclear how long it will take.
  
  Please remove these packages. I am also submitting a merge request to
  add them to the sync blocklist because they may still get Debian
  uploads. If gkrellm is ported to gtk2, gkrellm and the plugins that are
  compatible can sync to Ubuntu.
  
  - gkrellm
  - bfm
  - gkrellkam
  - gkrellm-leds
  - gkrellm-mailwatch
  - gkrellm-radio
  - gkrellm-reminder
  - gkrellm-tz
  - gkrellm-volume
  - gkrellmapcupsd
  - gkrellmoon
  - gkrellmwireless
  - gkrellshoot
  - gkrelltop
  - gkrellweather
  
  ********
  Analysis
  ********
  
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm
  Reverse-Depends
  ===============
  * gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltopd                    (for gkrellmd)
  * gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)
  
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm
  Reverse-Build-Depends
  =====================
  * bfm                           (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellmd)
  * gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)
  
  $ reverse-depends -b src:bfm
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:bfm
  Reverse-Recommends
  ==================
  * junior-system                 (for bubblefishymon)
  * junior-toys                   (for bubblefishymon)
  
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellkam
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellkam
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-leds
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-leds
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-mailwatch
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-mailwatch
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-radio
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-radio
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-reminder
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-reminder
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-tz
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-tz
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-volume
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-volume
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmapcupsd
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmapcupsd
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmoon
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmoon
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmwireless
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmwireless
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellshoot
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellshoot
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrelltop
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrelltop
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellweather
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellweather
  No reverse dependencies found

** Bug watch added: Debian Bug tracker #967406
   https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=967406

** Also affects: gkrellm (Debian) via
   https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=967406
   Importance: Unknown
       Status: Unknown

** Description changed:

  It would be nice to remove gtk2 from tenacious. Debian is unable to
  complete the removal of gtk2 because it is used in the Debian installer
  and it is complicated for the installer to switch to gtk3 because vte
  has switched to C++ in the new version. Since Ubuntu doesn't have that
  problem, Ubuntu can proceed. I think it makes sense to file separate
  bugs for different parts of the gtk2 removal, grouping where it makes
  sense.
  
  One app that is still maintained upstream and its packaging maintained
  in Debian is gkrellm. Upstream hasn't yet switched away from gtk3 and
  it's unclear how long it will take.
  
  Please remove these packages. I am also submitting a merge request to
  add them to the sync blocklist because they may still get Debian
  uploads. If gkrellm is ported to gtk2, gkrellm and the plugins that are
  compatible can sync to Ubuntu.
  
  - gkrellm
  - bfm
  - gkrellkam
  - gkrellm-leds
  - gkrellm-mailwatch
  - gkrellm-radio
  - gkrellm-reminder
  - gkrellm-tz
  - gkrellm-volume
  - gkrellmapcupsd
  - gkrellmoon
  - gkrellmwireless
  - gkrellshoot
  - gkrelltop
  - gkrellweather
  
  ********
  Analysis
  ********
+ 
+ https://transitions.ubuntu.com/html/gtk2-rm.html
  
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm
  Reverse-Depends
  ===============
  * gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltopd                    (for gkrellmd)
  * gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)
  
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm
  Reverse-Build-Depends
  =====================
  * bfm                           (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellkam                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-leds                  (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-mailwatch             (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-radio                 (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-reminder              (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-tz                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellm-volume                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmapcupsd                (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmoon                    (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellmwireless               (for gkrellm)
  * gkrellshoot                   (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellm)
  * gkrelltop                     (for gkrellmd)
  * gkrellweather                 (for gkrellm)
  
  $ reverse-depends -b src:bfm
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:bfm
  Reverse-Recommends
  ==================
  * junior-system                 (for bubblefishymon)
  * junior-toys                   (for bubblefishymon)
  
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellkam
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellkam
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-leds
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-leds
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-mailwatch
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-mailwatch
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-radio
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-radio
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-reminder
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-reminder
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-tz
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-tz
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellm-volume
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellm-volume
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmapcupsd
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmapcupsd
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmoon
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmoon
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellmwireless
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellmwireless
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellshoot
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellshoot
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrelltop
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrelltop
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends src:gkrellweather
  No reverse dependencies found
  $ reverse-depends -b src:gkrellweather
  No reverse dependencies found

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2173869

Title:
  Please remove gkrellm and its plugins from tenacious

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gkrellm/+bug/2173869/+subscriptions


-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to