Thank you digimer, and I apologize for getting the wrong email.

Booth was the piece I was missing.  Have been researching setting that up and 
finding a third location for quorum. From what I have found, I believe I will 
need to setup single node pacemaker clusters at each datacenter to use with 
booth. Since we have ESX clusters at each site which has its own redundancies 
built in, building redundant nodes at each site is pretty much a waste of 
resources imho. I have 2 questions about this setup though:

1.       If I setup pacemaker with a single node an no virtual IP, is there any 
problems I need to be aware of?

2.       Is drbd the best tool for the data sync between the sites? I've looked 
at drbd proxy, but I get the sense that it's not open source, or would rsync 
with incrond be a better option?

I already made a script that executes with the network startup that updates DNS 
using nsupdate so that should be easy to create a resource based on it I would 
think.

From: Digimer [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, April 17, 2020 11:01 AM
To: Daniel Smith <[email protected]>; Cluster Labs - Users 
<[email protected]>
Subject: Re: NFS in different subnets

EXTERNAL SENDER: Use caution with links/attachments.


Hi Daniel,

  You sent this to clusterlabs owners, instead of users. I've changed the CC to 
send it to the list for a larger discussion.

  The biggest problem with stretch clustering is knowing the difference between 
a link fault and a site loss. Pacemaker Booth was designed to solve this 
problem by using a "cluster of clusters". The logic being that if a site is 
lost, an arbiter node at a third site can decide which site should live, and 
trust the lost side will either behave sensibly (because it is itself a 
cluster), or it's destroyed.

  After this, it just becomes a question of implementation details. Have the 
master side update a DNS entry should be fine (though you may need to write a 
small resource agent to do it, not sure if one exists for DNS yet).

digimer
On 2020-04-17 11:44 a.m., Daniel Smith wrote:
I have been searching how to customize pacemaker to manage NFS servers in 
separate datacenters, but I am finding older data that suggests this is a bad 
idea and not much information about how to customize it to do this without the 
1 IP being moved back and forth. If this isn't the best tool, please let me 
know, but here is the setup I am trying to do if someone can help point me to 
some information on how the best way is to do this.

Server 1:              DC01-NFS01, 
10.0.1.10/24<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__10.0.1.10_24&d=DwQF-g&c=Wu-45Ur27gGDpxsjlug4Cg&r=q-8ZpsKaCLRx2o0mEXxy3Wwikv-bFgowvCmzCB6rH1g&m=55Uvz_i91WnbPX2YcZy4D8fuOxfKaswxUUQOUE8_3OM&s=KgYE6g5eRefvMqaVB3DF6zJehnQckYcqsjgq7F87OAw&e=>
Server 2:              DC02-NFS01, 
10.0.2.10/24<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__10.0.2.10_24&d=DwQF-g&c=Wu-45Ur27gGDpxsjlug4Cg&r=q-8ZpsKaCLRx2o0mEXxy3Wwikv-bFgowvCmzCB6rH1g&m=55Uvz_i91WnbPX2YcZy4D8fuOxfKaswxUUQOUE8_3OM&s=5DLmpw3KoLmznfpizJa1N-QMNJnZ6_uoiXbDs6kZETM&e=>
NFS share:           nfs01.domain.local:/opt/nfsmounts using drbd to sync 
between datacenters
DC01 to DC02 has a 2Gb layer 2 connection between the datacenters

I would like to have pacemaker manage the NFS services on both systems in an 
active/passive setup where it updates the DNS servers with the active server's 
IP for nfs01.domain.local. Eventually, we will have a virtual switch in VMWare 
that I would like pacemaker to update, but for now, the delay in DNS updates 
will be acceptable for failover.

Thank you in advance for any help you can provide.

Daniel Smith
Network Engineer
15894 Diplomatic Plaza Dr | Houston, TX 77032
P: 281-233-8487 | M: 832-301-1087
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
[cid:[email protected]]<https://craneww.com/>

--

Digimer

Papers and Projects: 
https://alteeve.com/w/<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__alteeve.com_w_&d=DwMF-g&c=Wu-45Ur27gGDpxsjlug4Cg&r=q-8ZpsKaCLRx2o0mEXxy3Wwikv-bFgowvCmzCB6rH1g&m=55Uvz_i91WnbPX2YcZy4D8fuOxfKaswxUUQOUE8_3OM&s=MKtKRVpHiCA-fhjJLdIO80wqBFRIS5gk160SJew523A&e=>

"I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein's 
brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and 
died in cotton fields and sweatshops." - Stephen Jay Gould
_______________________________________________
Manage your subscription:
https://lists.clusterlabs.org/mailman/listinfo/users

ClusterLabs home: https://www.clusterlabs.org/

Reply via email to