Hi,
After activating TxRep I always receive these warnings.
I use mysql for TxRep and I see a lot of "xxxxxxxx@sa_generated" entries
in the database, don't know if they are right.
I have activated all spamd debugs and included your block in TxRep. This
is the output:
===
rules: running one_line_body tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running head tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running body tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running uri tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running rawbody tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running full tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running meta tests; score so far=-2.601
check: running tests for priority: 1000
rules: running one_line_body tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running head tests; score so far=-2.601
rules: running head_eval tests; score so far=-2.601
learn: auto-learn: currently using scoreset 3, recomputing score based
on scoreset 1
learn: auto-learn: not considered head or body scores: -0.7
learn: auto-learn: message score: -2.601, computed score for autolearn: -0.7
dbiplugin: dbi:mysql:spam:1.1.1.1 need ping? yes
dbiplugin: Creating new database handle to
'spam:1.1.1.1_spam_xxxxxx_AutoCommit=1_PrintError=0_Username=yyyyyyyyy'
auto-whitelist: sql-based connected to DBI:mysql:spam:1.1.1.1
auto-whitelist: sql-based using username: xxxxxxxxxx
TxRep: Parameters: self:
Mail::SpamAssassin::Plugin::TxRep=HASH(0x2ac2918) storage: pms:
Mail::SpamAssassin::PerMsgStatus=HASH(0x4690360), key: MSG_ID, id:
34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated, ip: , signedby:
1430826824, msgscore:
TxRep: weight: 1
TxRep: undefined - Caller Info: Package:
Mail::SpamAssassin::Plugin::TxRep - Filename:
/usr/lib/perl5/site_perl/5.16.2/Mail/SpamAssassin/Plugin/TxRep.pm -
Line: 1371
auto-whitelist: sql-based get_addr_entry: no entries found for
34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated|1430826824
auto-whitelist: sql-based
34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated|1430826824 scores
0, count 0
check: tagrun - tag TXREP_MSG_ID is now ready, value: 0.0
check: tagrun - tag TXREP_MSG_ID_COUNT is now ready, value: 0.0
check: tagrun - tag TXREP_MSG_ID_PRESCORE is now ready, value: -2.6
TxRep: reputation: none, count: 0, weight: 1.0, delta: 0.000, MSG_ID:
34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated
auto-whitelist: sql-based add_score/insert score 0:
xxxxxxx|34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated|none|1|0|1430826824
TxRep: message 34a82b329b230df129b3b12a5bf6cc7e2ab93cd2@sa_generated
already scanned, using old data; post-TxRep score: -2.368
rules: running body tests; score so far=-2.368
rules: running uri tests; score so far=-2.368
rules: running rawbody tests; score so far=-2.368
rules: running full tests; score so far=-2.368
rules: running meta tests; score so far=-2.368
===
TxRep.pm - Line: 1371
===
sub check_reputations {
###########################################################################
my $self = shift;
my $delta;
if ($self->open_storages()) {
if ($self->{conf}->{txrep_user2global_ratio} &&
$self->{user_storage} != $self->{global_storage}) {
my $user = $self->check_reputation('user_storage', @_);
my $global = $self->check_reputation('global_storage',@_);
$delta = (defined $user && $user==$user) ?
( $self->{conf}->{txrep_user2global_ratio} * $user + $global
) / ( 1 + $self->{conf}->{txrep_user2global_ratio} ) :
$global;
} else {
1371: ==> $delta = $self->check_reputation(undef,@_);
}
}
return $delta;
}
===
Regards,
Carlos Velasco
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: TxRep $msgscore warning
From: Kevin A. McGrail <kmcgr...@pccc.com>
To: J.J. Day <day1...@hotmail.com>, Joe Quinn <jqu...@pccc.com>
Cc: "users@spamassassin.apache.org" <users@spamassassin.apache.org>,
Date: Thu, 30 Apr 2015 13:15:07 -0400
> On 4/30/2015 11:44 AM, J.J. Day wrote:
>> FWIW, I switched to TxRep several months ago. Every message generates
>> both error lines. I have added a test to initialize $msgscore to
>> avoid filling my log files. Spam messages seem to all generate a
>> negative offset of ~1/3 the total. I copied a sample to the end.
>>
>> My setup is:
>> FreeBSD 10.0
>> Sendmail 8.14.7
>> Mimedefang 2.75
>> SpamAssassin 3.4.0
>> Cyrus 2.4.17
>>
>> I hope this helps.
> Interesting. So you are using the API. On your same box if you run
> spamassassin -t with your sample, can you recreate the issue?
>
> Otherwise, the sample doesn't help us because we can't recreate the
> issue, unfortunately.
>
>
> DFS, with MD calling SA as an API, how do you turn on a debug
> channel? Happen to know?
>
>
> Can you add this block of code above line 1386 in the current
> TxRep.pm? Then we'll try and figure out how to enable the TxRep debug
> channel from MD so you can log the info and relay it. It also should
> hide the informat
>
>
> {
> #Bug 7164, trying to find out reason for these: _WARN: Use of
> uninitialized value $msgscore in addition (+) at
> /usr/share/perl5/vendor_perl/Mail/SpamAssassin/Plugin/TxRep.pm line 1415.
> no warnings;
>
> unless (defined $msgscore) {
> #Output some params and the calling function so we can identify
> more about this bug
> dbg("TxRep: Parameters: self: $self storage: $storage pms: $pms,
> key: $key, id: $id, ip: $ip, signedby: $signedby, msgscore: $msgscore");
> dbg("TxRep: weight: $weight");
>
> my ($package, $filename, $line) = caller();
>
> chomp($package);
> chomp($filename);
> chomp($line);
>
> dbg("TxRep: $msgscore undefined - Caller Info: Package: $package
> - Filename: $filename - Line: $line");
>
> #Define $msgscore as a triage to hide warnings while we find the
> root cause
> $msgscore = 0;
> }
> }
>
> Here's more detail about where it needs to be:
>
> sub check_reputation {
> ###########################################################################
>
> my ($self, $storage, $pms, $key, $id, $ip, $signedby, $msgscore) = @_;
>
> my $delta = 0;
> my $weight = ($key eq 'MSG_ID')? 1 :
> eval('$pms->{main}->{conf}->{txrep_weight_'.lc($key).'}');
>
> --> Block here
>
> if (defined $weight && $weight) {
>
> Regards,
> KAM
