Today at 12:41am, Ryan Cox said:

>Finally, someone called me up, asked me to post the log of the FTP
>conversation, and then asked around (which is what I expect them to do)
>when he wasn't quite sure what reverse DNS was.  I was pleased to talk
>with this guy because even though he didn't know about DNS, he at least
>asked someone who did instead of saying simply "we don't support
>[whatever it is that you are talking about]", and then he asked a
>higher-up why reverse DNS wasn't allowed. After that I got the response:
>
>I was informed that reverse DNS will NOT work with the NATed IP
>addresses of the ResNet halls for security measures. I called back Ryan
>and told him that.
>
>----------
>
>But I'm still not sure if there really are any security implications
>that would justify this.  After all, if the server at the IP address
>that is mapped to is properly configured and firewalled, then what's the
>problem?  They don't forward any ports or anything.

They're basing the decision on bad information... there's absolutely
nothing wrong with doing RDNS for NAT'd IPs. It makes no difference if
they're NAT'd or not, as long as you're using the IPs on the public side
of the NAT. It can even be a single entry for a big block that simply
_includes_ the NAT's external addresses.

Try to reopen it asking what the security issues are. If you want to get
all technical on them, send them some references to the RFCs that describe
RDNS, and other articles that discuss it, so they know that you know what
you're talking about. (If you're lucky, when some of them realize that you
know something that they don't, and that you are probably right, they'll
come around. But, this is an educational institution, and a private one
at that, so it may not happen any time soon.) Maybe talking to their DNS
"specialist" would help, if they have one.

>btw, I especially liked the "He is just trying to do some crazy stuff"
>quote.

What people don't understand, they mock... :)

Mac

--
Mac Newbold             MNE - Mac Newbold Enterprises, LLC
[EMAIL PROTECTED]       http://www.macnewbold.com/

____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to