From: Jed Rothwell 

Can someone please describe how they are measuring output power? Where is the 
evidence of gain?

*       It is basically a temperature comparison, which is not the best method, 
but the temperature difference is large. 

“Not the best method”? Without proper calibration, this is not a method at all. 
Even with calibration, it is considered sub-standard.

1)      Where is the calibration ?
2)      Type K is a general purpose thermocouple which may be used up to 1260 
°C in an inert atmosphere. In oxidizing atmospheres the safe limit is 800 °C. 
Type K should never have been used in air (or hydrogen) above 800 °C.
3)      One thermocouple failed prematurely, which can be expected when 
operating in air, and this implies the others are compromised.
4)      Without proper working thermocouples, and without proper calibration, 
this report should never have been published. Jiang has a nice looking setup  
here, so how hard would it have been to do it right?
*       
*       JR: 405 deg C is a huge difference.

Yes, but it is proof of nothing other than an inverted temperature profile.

*       Assuming the thermocouples are working correctly, this indicates that 
much of the heat originates from inside the cell rather than the resistance 
heater. It is hard to judge how much heat there is. 

Yes, it does look like heat originates inside the cell but without calorimetry, 
we have no proof of anything other than an inverted temperature profile – for 
which there is the mundane explanation.

Most of us want to believe that an inverted temperature profile means net gain, 
but that is not necessarily true. When hydrogen expands, such as when it is 
released from a compound like LAH – it HEATS up, instead of cools down. This is 
because of the low inversion temperature of hydrogen. This heating factor can 
add heat to the inside of the cell, which is chemical in nature. If and when 
calorimetry proves there is gain above chemical, then we can eliminate the 
inversion temperature of hydrogen as contributory BUT NOT BEFORE.

In short – some of all of the temperature difference here can be explained as 
the heating effect of hydrogen being released from LAH – and only calorimetry 
will prove otherwise.


Reply via email to