Jed,
Yes I was referring to high school grads for that rating, but it really doesn't matter. It is not so much the college grads that will be losing their jobs (although some like pharmacists etc will.) it is more that there won't be other jobs to go to.

For a more pessimistic look see below. Also a very funny summary about the presidential candidates.
http://fredoneverything.org/ready-ronald-mcdonald-or-lucretia-borgia-in-the-long-run-we-are-all-dead/

AA

On 10/22/2016 4:02 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
a.ashfield <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    It could have been written more clearly with half the number of words.
    They seem to think that displaced workers can be retrained for
    better jobs, something that seems increasingly unlikely with
    current graduates dead last in the world in math and science.


U.S. college grads are first in math and science. Perhaps you mean high school graduates. That statistic is somewhat suspect because a higher fraction of the population graduates from highschool in the U.S. than from some other countries.

The same problem confuses a discussion on the effects of funding on education. People have noted that New York and Massachusetts spend far more per capita on primary education than, say, Alabama or North Dakota even taking into account regional consumer cost differences. New York is the highest in the world, I think, at $19,818 per child. Yet SAT scores in North Dakota are higher than New York, 1799 versus 1463. This is taken as proof that spending money on education does not work.

That argument falls apart when you look at the fraction of students taking the SAT test. 76% of kids in New York take the test, lowering the average score. Only 7% of the kids in Alabama take the SAT, and 2% in North Dakota. The top 2% of New York kids are far ahead of the 2% of kids in North Dakota who take the SAT. I believe the top 2% of kids from New York probably have the highest academic scores in the world. They are ahead of the average kids in Japan, and equal to the elite in Japan, in my opinion. I base that on my somewhat subjective experience in elite schools and universities in New York state and in Japan.

See:

https://ballotpedia.org/Public_education_in_New_York

https://ballotpedia.org/Public_education_in_Alabama

https://ballotpedia.org/Public_education_in_North_Dakota

Reply via email to