The markets world-wide are not reacting to who may be the president in
the US and what he might do. They are reacting to real events in the
financial world and the anticipation that a world-wide depression is
underway. Until the dead wood is out of the market, no one can have
much effect. The issue is who do you want to pick up the pieces, unite
the country, and put people back to work. Do you want an old guy who
has demonstrated a belief in the failed ideology or a young guy who at
least describes another way? The stakes are too high to make a
mistake this time as was done in the past.
As for a letter, someone will be asked to describe exactly how the
requested money will be spent, exactly who will do the work, and when
the promised results can be expected. Without a rational and
scientifically correct answer, all of the written letters will be
useless. If someone wants to actually attract funding, they need to
provide this required information. This is a fact of life that needs
to be discussed before a lot of time is wasted writing letters that
will be answered by form letters sent by the staff of the candidate.
If for some miracle a scientific adviser should respond, if this
information cannot be supplied in a timely manner, all of the effort
will be wasted. No matter how real CF is, people at that level need
exact information that can stand review by trusted scientists. If the
answer looks weak or inaccurate, the first impression will be
negative. So, I suggest we in the field get our act together before
sending letters that might cause this information to be requested.
Ed
On Oct 27, 2008, at 8:40 AM, R C Macaulay wrote:
Perhaps what the world stock markets are saying is...
"Neither candidate or party for the US presidency has what it takes
to lead. "
However, we must try and a letter is a step.
Richard
OrionWorks wrote:
FWIW, one of Joe Biden's science advisers is the ever irascible Dr.
Peter Zimmerman. I gather he still advises Biden on occasion on
scientific matters . . .
Yikes. That man is impossible to deal with. He and Park are still on
the warpath against cold fusion.
Maybe Dr. Zimmerman's POV has tempered somewhat since those early
exchanges, but that's a long shot a best.
I wouldn't bother with him.
IOW, getting Obama's ear might prove to be difficult.
If people like Zimmerman are his gatekeepers it will prove
impossible.
- Jed