>Stephen: Is there a simple, concise explanation of why a hydrogen atom can't spontaneously collapse to a hydrino, by radiating away the transition energy as a photon? I.e., why is a collision with a catalyst necessary?
> PVN: Regarding the groundstate of the H atom: in Mills theory the > ordinary groundstate is the first level of a series of 137 which can only be reached by energy transfer through collision. No fotons are emited when energy is released. > RC: Below n = 1 won't you require selection rules to prevent emission of photons. You see I find this bogus. You say the energy is given over in collisions so just what do you think are the expression of those forces? > RC: Also Jones, Steven, there's a nice quick proof in Feynman III about the size of atoms where he uses the Uncertainty Principle in a 1/r well. Since the charges are the same, to get any lower must mean that 'h' has changed. How, why? -----Original Message----- From: Stephen A. Lawrence [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 30 October 2008 21:12 To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Vo]: Mills' recapitalisation of energy levels Mike Carrell wrote: > ... The "ground state" is > simply the relaxed state in a vacuum, neither ionized nor catalyzed. > Mills' discovery is that the fractional state can be reached by > selective catalysis under special conditions. I have a Very Dumb Question here. Is there a simple, concise explanation of why a hydrogen atom can't spontaneously collapse to a hydrino, by radiating away the transition energy as a photon? I.e., why is a collision with a catalyst necessary? If the only simple answer is "Don't be so lazy, Read The Book", well, whatever ... but I'm hoping it's possible for someone here to give an approximate summary of the reason in a few sentences.

