On quick inspection of this and scan reading (how one always reads stuff
first) some points:

#1 Feynman is one of the greatest ever educators and he has simple little
footnotes and tricks to get you rough and ready answers. Much like the
famous Chopin (or Schuman?) saying, "you will be a solid pianist if Bach is
your daily bread". I keep him to hand always when starting from the ground
up on some problem. That one on calculating the sizes of atoms gets the
crucial ideas across quickly and is correct.

#2 The Uncertainty relation doesn't really 'come from' the Schrodinger
Equation, however it does pop out from the Fourier Transform and waves. It
really came about as the old quantum mechanics with ad-hoc Summerfield
quantisation rules were systematically thought over by Heisenberg's Matrix
Mechanics. At the core he explored the ideas of conjugate variables not
commuting. Jordon showed that Schrodinger's approach is the same as
Heisenberg and once again Feynman gives a brilliant 'derivation' of the S.E.
using matrix mechanics and the state approach taken in the limit.

So these are just points of presentation on the history of science which may
appear pedantic. 

# Argument 1 on page 7 is wrong.

Delta a x delta p = h

Feynman does precisely this. 'a' the size is precisely delta 'a' if the
centre is 'zero'. Likewise in this 'little solar system' model 'p' is delta
'p' if your zero is zero. The motions are define wrt to the centre of the
system.

He is not doing delta (a x p) = h as is claimed.

# Argument 2 on page 7 see point #2 above. As regards the equation 'kinetic
energy of rotation' he lists and reference [20] I don't have it to hand but
looking at that equation it is a mishmash of a classical equation and a
quantum result. You can't expect it to be totally right. When Feynman does
that it is to get a rough and ready result. Since the formula is wrong Mills
conclusion is then wrong. ***Don't extrapolate results with wrong
formulas.***

You can't talk about 'kinetic energy of rotation' it is a classical concept,
the electron doesn't rotate but takes on a waveform centred over the atom.
It is precisely why QM was created when Maxwell came up with EM theory -
atoms would radiate down to nothing. Classical concepts are easy heuristics
and you must apply the correct quantum equations. 

Nobody else works like this. They would begin with 'let's get a rough and
ready calculation', 'let's get a feel of the magnitude of things'. He is say
its correct!!!

I can't be bothered to read the rest because everything else is based on
these howlers.
 
Building a thesis is like building a house - the foundations must be secure.


-----Original Message-----
From: Jones Beene [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: 30 October 2008 21:37
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [Vo]: Mills' recapitalisation of energy levels



Remi, Stephen:


> RC: Also Jones, Steven, there's a nice quick proof in Feynman III about
the size of atoms where he uses the Uncertainty Principle in a 1/r well.
Since the charges are the same, to get any lower must mean that 'h' has
changed. How, why?

The World According to Mills:


The  Fallacy of Feynman's Argument on the Stability of the Hydrogen  Atom
According to Quantum Mechanics 


-  R.L. Mills, Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie,  Vol. 30, No. 2,
(2005), pp. 129-151.

http://www.ensmp.fr/aflb/AFLB-302/aflb302m185.pdf



Reply via email to