-----Original Message-----
From: Horace Heffner 

> In fact, some molecular orbitals exist in a figure 8 configuration, where
the center of the 8 is the nucleus, thus guaranteeing constant nuclear
traverses.  

[JB:] Understanding the figure 8 configuration is perhaps the most important
basic challenge in QM and it can also be said that most theorists are simply
not "up to the task".

However, I would add that "guaranteeing constant nuclear traverses" is a bit
of a reach in this regard ....

The following observation may or may not help with that understanding of 2p
orbitals- but - if you think about a capacitor as being able to "pass" AC
current, and current consists of, well it consists at least partly of
electrons - then the nuclear-cap can be a decent analogy (i.e with the
nucleus as a kind of capacitor)... but of course there is the argument that
it is "not the same electron"...

However, in Dirac's universe - is not the electron the epitome of
"fungibility"?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fungibility

When I wrote that word "fungibility" I was almost certain that it would not
be in Wiki, but heck, it is getting pretty damn hard to come up with
anything that is not in Wiki these daze...

Jones

BTW here is some interesting commentary on 2p orbitals that adds some
credence to the idea that indeed it is "not the same electron" that crosses
the nucleus ...

http://winter.group.shef.ac.uk/orbitron/AOs/2p/index.html


Reply via email to