On Thu, Nov 17, 2011 at 11:04 PM, Marcello Vitale <[email protected]>wrote:
> Rich, are you talking about Mary and those who, like her, keep saying they > KNOW what is going on despite lacking all knowledge, experience, > understanding, skill, intuition.......? :-)))) > Marcello, I asked you before. What are you writing about? I don't understand you and you're talking about me and saying incorrect things! I never said I knew "what's going on" in terms of the details of what Rossi is doing. He doesn't provide enough information to know exactly. I just dislike how it looks and smells. Despite that, I never said I knew for certain that he was a scammer or that I had proof of a scam. As for knowledge, experience, understanding, and skill, I once was part of team who designed calorimeters not unlike those that Rossi could use to prove that his smaller E-cats behave as he says. What more experience, etc., would you want? So, sorry, but you're incorrect unless I misunderstood you. I do have the skills required to evaluate some if not all aspects of Rossi's experiments -- I stick to what I know. And I am NOT saying I "KNOW" what is going on with Rossi behind the scenes. Maybe we could have a better discussion if you stuck to issues such as the need for independent testing. Rossi continues to refuse to get it despite Celani's excellent and entirely reasonable offer. Why don't you discuss why Rossi doesn't take up Celani? If Celani proved Rossi right, it would end the skeptical chatter you seem to dislike so much.
