On Tue, Nov 22, 2011 at 9:17 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> wrote:

> the tobacco industry stopped cancer research;
>

No, they didn't. They slowed down public acceptance of the danger, and
government action against smoking. But from the earliest evidence, the
medical establishment accepted the link between smoking and cancer.

No one denies that industries will lobby against measures that hurt their
profit. That's not the same as scientists lobbying against the reality of a
phenomenon. Scientists' can't buy ferraris with their grants. And switching
research areas will ordinarily not impact their personal wealth. In fact,
switching away from a field which will be obsoleted by a new phenomenon is
probably better for their careers. Certainly, suppressing a field that
turns out to save mankind will no look good on anyone's nomination for a
nobel prize.

All these lame examples, which bear almost no resemblance to cold fusion,
are just excuses made by a lot of people who really wish cold fusion were
true. Or as Randi put it, who *need* it to be true.


> Heck, Microsoft squashed a large fraction of the reliable PC software in
> the 1980s, replacing it with dreck. Bill Gates became the richest man in
> the world mainly by suppressing good ideas and good products such as
> WordPerfect. He still has the money, although he is presently at a trial
> testifying about WordPerfect.
>

Lamest comparison yet. Competition between software? How is that like the
discovery of new phenomena?



> For one thing they'll always triumph if they're real.
>
>
> That is incorrect. In most cases, when a discovery such as the transistor
> is revealed, a careful search of the literature shows that it has been
> discovered and forgotten many times in the past.
>

Not in areas where hundreds of scientists are searching for it
relentlessly, like in cold fusion. Heat of the sort claimed, and radiation,
and transmutation can not stay hidden for decades unless it's not real. And
not in areas where the result is revolutionary, like cold fusion would be.

And the transistor was not discovered and forgotten many times. There were
related patents written in the 20s, but almost no activity. When people
worked on it in the 40s, it took only a few years to a clear demonstration
of amplification.

>
> That is also impossible to test or falsify. How can you be sure that
> nothing has been lost?
>

You can't of course, but if it were common, some things rejected as bogus
by mainstream  for decades would be vindicated. That has happened rarely,
and mainly in fields like geology, cosmology, and paleontology, all of
which are greedy with data. It is almost unheard of for bench top
experiments in the physical sciences, especially when the observables are
simple like heat and radiation.

Reply via email to