My understanding concurs with Robin's, that they need to be in-phase. However, as Axil pointed out in his reference to a PhysOrg article which states: "These polaritons overwhelmingly prefer to march in step with each other, entangling themselves quantum mechanically."
Not sure if that experiment was at near 0K, or >273K. When thinking about all the work on BECs, when one removes all heat energy the individual oscillations will establish phase coherence... kind of like women's menstrual cycles all coming into sync when they live in close proximity! (Never thought I'd have a good use for that tidbit of info!) :-) However, I think the comments by Axil are referring to situations where there is a considerable amount of thermal energy present (normal temps)??? In that case, and in bulk matter, the heat quanta are shuffling around the lattice in a random and non-coherent manner so one is dealing with, well, 'bulk' matter! And due to the randomness of the heat quanta doin' the Texas Two-Step shuffle, one has to use probabilities to describe atomic processes. Understand that heat quanta cause the oscillations of the subatomic elements of atoms to become slightly out of sync, and imparts a little extra momentum to one of the elements, which 'unbalances' it (makes its oscillations no longer harmonic with other elements), and that causes the entire assemblage (atom) to vibrate. Imagine the wheel of a car being an electron, which is perfectly balanced and rotates perfectly. Now add a lead weight (a quantum of heat), and the wheel now is wobbling all around since it is 'out of balance'. That in turn causes the entire car to shimmy. The glue holding the lead weight can't stand the stress and the lead weight is ejected. This is where one begins to respect the fact that solid matter is really only an illusion; *solid* matter is only what we perceive at the size and timescale of our senses/perception. When one gets down to nanometers and attoseconds, it's all oscillations of *something*... god forbid I call it aether. -Mark -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, January 17, 2012 7:59 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Vo]:Cooper pairing of protons In reply to Axil Axil's message of Sun, 8 Jan 2012 02:35:02 -0500: Hi, [snip] >Where N can be 1 to very many, N identical waves are said to be coherent. >These many waves have the same waveform; they are all in fact the same >wave. Since particles are matter waves, N particles that are identical >and indistinguishable are coherent. These matter waves can be made >identical by any number of resonance interactions. I think that to be coherent they also need to be in phase, which is nearly impossible to achieve if they are in motion relative to one another. Regards, Robin van Spaandonk http://rvanspaa.freehostia.com/project.html

