On Thu, May 3, 2012 at 9:29 AM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:
You are assuming that hydrogen is the only element that can be used in an > LENR reaction. This should be verified. > You bring up an excellent point. My wording was not careful enough -- I should have made reference to known systems in the statement about ionization of hydrogen or deuterium. I have wondered what might happen in a larger lattice with larger larger ions. There might be something interesting that happens, or there might be a cyclical reaction that doesn't go anywhere. I suspect that the statement that neutrons do not initiate cold fusion > reactions might not always be correct. One would expect a slow moving > neutron that happens upon a nucleus would be absorbed and give off a large > amount of energy and other reaction components. This new influx of energy > might trigger the coming events. > I personally am inclined against the statement about neutrons -- I'm rooting for a neutron reaction. When I say that I like the limitations proposed by Ed Storms, I mean this in the sense that they are potentially falsifiable, so they can be found to be true or false. I wish they were more concrete, however, and in that sense they're not quite what I had in mind, since I'm looking for statements that could potentially be tested in specific experiments. Storms seems to have general ground rules in mind for any explanation. Does the reference to two products include energy as one and > the transformed nucleus as the other? > Perhaps -- the explanation in the book seems to indicate that the limitation is being proposed in order to avoid magical reaction equations; e.g., throwing out conservation of momentum. I think you should add an expectation that temperature affects the reaction > rates in general. Rossi's device does not begin producing heat until it is > at a minimum temperature. > I like that -- maybe something like, - A reaction stops if the temperature goes above a certain threshold, after which the substrate becomes unusable. - Below a certain threshold, there is a direct correlation between temperature and heat. Both of these statements assume that there's always heat -- that itself might be an interesting assumption to investigate. Eric

