Well, Bob - this would depend on which isotopes of Ni are involved, as some
reaction could be gainful - but one thing that almost every expert agrees
on, is that if-and-when Nickel does transmute to Copper, one cannot end-up
with a natural copper isotope ratio as the ash. 

 

Moreover, there will be some percentage of radioactive species (copper or
otherwise) with detectably long half-life (months to years) - and these will
be extraordinarily easy to document if they are present.

 

The reason that these isotopes have not been documented (by the Swedes, for
instance) can most likely be attributed to the fact that nickel is NOT
transmuting into copper (or anything else) for most of the gain in this
reaction. They would have detected tritium or almost any other radioactive
isotope, if present - since they had access to the unshielded spent-fuel
from Rossi to test.

 

 

From: Bob Higgins 

 

Peter Hagelstein says that transmutation of nickel to copper is overall
endothermic.

If you want to show the heat came from the transmutation - that is a far
different story, and Piantelli or no one else has come close to a
correlation of the heat radiated to the tiny amount of transmutation.

 

Reply via email to