On Sun, May 12, 2013 at 12:47 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com>wrote:

> I have often cited this paper, which describes the final results from
> Toyota's lab in France:
>


The results were presented in 1996. The lab closed in 1998. How could they
be final, unless they got nothing in the last 2 years.



> FAKE. This was published by Toyota researchers at conference sponsored by
> a Japanese government agency (NEDO). It would be out of character for
> Toyota or NEDO to countenance fake data. They would surely know it is fake.
>
>

I don't know if they were fake, but between out-of-character and
revolutionary physics, the former is more likely, especially in view of the
subsequent shut-down of the lab, and absence of any subsequent comparable
results.




> MISTAKE. As you see in the paper, the temperatures were high and easy to
> measure, and the input to output ratio was high. I do not think there is
> any chance this was a mistake.
>
>

But it was inferior calorimetry, and it used boiling water. Rossi is a
master at the boiling water fake, getting a factor of 7 out of it. Pons
only managed a factor of 2 or so.

Reply via email to