Two questions: 1) Why do you think "contributor genders" write articles about people? 2) Why do you want to explore the relationship between the genders of articles about people and the genders of the contributors to those articles?
It's more interesting to discover how well the Wikipedia article gender ratios per occupation/period measure up to the various supporting (academic) literature databases used as references for those articles. On Fri, May 22, 2020 at 2:14 PM Baptiste Fontaine <b...@ptistefontaine.fr> wrote: > Hello, > > Due to a lot of free time these days I started a personal research project > on gender bias in contributors to the French-language Wikipedia. > > My goal is to explore the relation between contributor genders and the > people they create articles about. The hypotheses are: > 1- contributors predominantly write biographies of people with the same > gender. Simplistically: men write about men; women write about women. > 2- there are a lot fewer female contributors than male ones. This has been > studied in the past but AFAIK we don’t have recent numbers and they are > all on the English-language WP. > > If these two hypotheses are true, this could explain part of the problem > with gender bias in biographies. > > What I’m struggling with –And I guess some people before me did as well on > the English-language WP– is the very low level of information we have on > contributors’ genders: on WP:FR, 60-70% of contributors have not changed > their gender in their user settings. > > Does anyone have any pointer on this? > > > More insights below: > > Looking at the contributors with ≥500 edits, 2.4% are auto-declared as > female; 27.4% as male; 70.2% as 'unknown' (undeclared). > > By definition, there’s no apparent way to know the approximate gender > repartition of the undeclared-gender accounts. > > The French-language Wikipedia shows male- and unknown-gender user pages > with the 'Utilisateur:' prefix while the female-gender user pages use the > 'Utilisatrice:' prefix. Based on this, one would assume that women would > be more inclined toward declaring their gender so that the interface would > stop misgendering them. However, we know that female users tend to > under-declare their gender to protect themselves. > > I assumed that older accounts would be more inclined toward having a > declared gender but that’s not the case: >60% of accounts of all ages > (except the very old ones but the sample is very small) have not declared > their gender, see: > > > https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Gender_repartition_of_Le_Bistro_WP-fr_users_by_account_age.png > > Some users have user boxes on their user page with various info. Some of > them declare their gender. Surprisingly however, most of the users with > these boxes have not declared their gender in their preferences. > > Out of the 434 users with a "I’m a woman" user box on their page, only > 32% are auto-declared as female. Same ratio for the 2773 "I’m a man" users: > only 34% are auto-declared as male. It goes up to 36 % for the "I’m a > lesbian" box (N=14) and 40% for the "I’m a gay" one (N=86). > > As I expected, predominantly-male professions have a larger male population > in their box usage, but still an even larger 'unknown' population: > Out of the 640 "I’m an engineer" box users, 24% self-declared as 'male' and > 1% as 'female'. For the 714 "I’m a computers person", that’s 27.7% and > 0.6%. > > However some boxes where I wouldn’t expect a large bias have one as well. > The Babel Italian users are 18% male and 2% female (N=2885). The Esperanto > ones are 24.5% male and 0.8% female (N=493). > > There is certainly a bias in box usage: newer users tend to use them a lot > less than older users, and I would assume users who talk about themselves > with boxes don’t have the same profile as the average contributor. > > > Thanks, > > -- > Baptiste Fontaine > > > _______________________________________________ > Wiki-research-l mailing list > Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org > https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l > _______________________________________________ Wiki-research-l mailing list Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l
