bawolff <bawolff+wn <at> gmail.com> writes: > [...] > > >> All loaded javascript should > >> be included in the extension (Loading js hosted on other sites is not > >> allowed on Wikipedia in order to protect user privacy) > > That is very hard. I have no access to the GeoGebra JS, although it > > is basically open source. This is in contradiction to the concepts > > of GeoGebra - load its JavaScript from geogebra.org to get always > > the newest version. > > This is definitely a hard requirement. We need all code loaded by > Wikipedia and friends to be in in the repo, to ensure that other sites > don't collect inappropriate analytics (violating our privacy policy), > or deliver malicious content. Well I'm sure that GeoGebra would not do > either of those things, the general principle is that we want to be > sure to be in control of all code, so that we know for sure we would > never have to worry about that sort of thing. > > [...] > > -- > -bawolff > Hi, bawolff,
let me summarize: * The problem how to embed GeoGebra into a Mediawiki is technically solved. The solution is tested on different wikis and has been refined over years. * Installing the GeoGebra extension at Wikipedia should be a win-win situation: Wikipedia could be improved by many dynamic geometric drawings instead of static pictures. GeoGebra could improve its publicity. * Nevertheless the GeoGebra extension may not be installed at Wikipedia for security reasons (and avoiding inappropriate analytics). On Friday 03/04/2016 I visited the ZUM workshop [1] at Schweinfurt, Germany. ZUM = Zentrale für Unterrichtsmedien im Internet [2] The OER-AWARD 2016 was awarded to the ZUM Wiki at Berlin. [3], [4] I had the opportunity for some talks with other members of ZUM, and finally made up my mind: * I am no member of the GeoGebra team. * I am no Mediawiki hacker and no member of Wikimedia. * It should be easier for the GeoGebra team and the Mediawiki team to collaborate directly and solve the security issue problem. * I will stop my personal efforts to get GeoGebra into Wikipedia. -- -Rudi [1] http://www.zum.de/portal/blog/ZUMTeam/ZUM-Workshop-2016-zumworks16 [2] http://www.zum.de/portal/ [3] http://open-educational-resources.de/16/award/ [4] http://wikis.zum.de/zum/OER-Award_2016_f%C3%BCr_das_ZUM-Wiki _______________________________________________ Wikitech-l mailing list Wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l
