Francois Gouget wrote:
On Thu, 12 Apr 2007, Maarten Lankhorst wrote:
[...]
I'm not sure what nas is for, but it seems to be 'network audio system',
I haven't seen any use for it, except that it causes a 30 seconds
slowdown at showing 'audio' tab in winecfg. I don't think anyone uses it.
For esd I think it's best to remove, for nas I'm also for remove, but
I'll settle for removing it from winecfg list same way as winearts was
disabled for a while.
NAS is used to get sound on X terminals. It would be interesting to get
input from the LTSP and thin-client crowd before concluding it can be
removed.
We use Wine with only ESD for our terminals. From what I gather, most
LTSP systems use only ESD, but NAS is the second most popular.
By the way, in LTSP, ESD's major deficiency is not being able to control
the volume from things like the GNOME sound applet, so there's some
interest in (but no support for) changing to PulseAudio.
There's some info here:
http://wiki.ltsp.org/twiki/bin/view/Ltsp/Sound
Andrew
