Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Krish and Prabha, Thanks for your replies. I still have some follow-up questions: 1) I read https://docs.docker.com/trusted-content/official-images/ and didn't find anything on that page or immediately around it that explains what compliance requirements might be satisfied by a DOI that

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hey Chris, We have responded to the initial round of queries. And as you mentioned in your comment, you may have more questions related to this KIP. Please let us know if you have any. We want to start the voting for this KIP soon, as we intend to include it in the 3.8.0 release. Thanks.

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Chris. Thanks for the questions. 3. Would a separate Docker-owned repository be out of the question? I'm > guessing there are some trademark issues that might get in the way, but > it's worth exploring since the entire purpose of this KIP seems to be to > provide images that are vetted and

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Chris, I would like to add more context to this KIP's motivation. Vedarth and Krish, please weigh in with your inputs. In the motivation section it's stated that "Several other Apache projects, > like Flink, Spark, Solr, have already released Docker Official Images, with > download figures

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Vedarth and Krish, Thanks for the KIP! I have to admit I'm a little skeptical; hopefully you can help me understand the need for these additional images. 1) In the motivation section it's stated that "Several other Apache projects, like Flink, Spark, Solr, have already released Docker

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hey folks, Thanks a lot for reviewing the KIP and providing feedback. The discussion thread seems resolved and KIP has been updated accordingly. We will be starting the voting thread for this KIP in the next few days. Please take a look at the KIP and let us know if any further discussion is

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Thanks Krish. KIP looks good to me. On Wed, Apr 17, 2024 at 1:38 PM Krish Vora wrote: > > Hi Manikumar, > > Thanks for the comments. > > Maybe as part of the release process, RM can create a JIRA for this > > task. This can be taken by RM or any comitter or any contributor (with > > some help

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Manikumar, Thanks for the comments. Maybe as part of the release process, RM can create a JIRA for this > task. This can be taken by RM or any comitter or any contributor (with > some help from commiters to run "Docker Image Preparation via GitHub > Actions:" This sounds like a good idea.

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Krish, Thanks for the updated KIP. a few comments below. > "These actions can be carried out by the RM or any contributor post the > release process." Maybe as part of the release process, RM can create a JIRA for this task. This can be taken by RM or any comitter or any contributor (with

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Manikumar and Luke. Thanks for the questions. 1. No, the Docker inventory files and configurations will not be the same for Open Source Software (OSS) Images and Docker Official Images (DOI). For OSS images, the Dockerfile located in docker/jvm/dockerfile is utilized. This process is

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Krishna, I also have the same question as Manikumar raised: 1. Will the Docker inventory files/etc are the same for OSS Image and Docker Official Images? If no, then why not? Could we make them identical so that we don't have to build 2 images for each release? Thank you. Luke On Wed, Apr 3,

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Krishna, Thanks for the KIP. I think Docker Official Images will be beneficial to the Kafka community. Few queries below. 1. Will the Docker inventory files/etc are the same for OSS Image and Docker Official Images 2. I am a bit worried about the new steps to the release process. Maybe we

Re: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi Hector, Thanks for reaching out. This KIP builds on top of KIP-975 and aims to introduce a JVM-based Docker Official Image (DOI ) for Apache

Re:[DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka

Hi, What is the difference between this KIP and KIP-975: Docker Image for Apache Kafka? From: dev@kafka.apache.org At: 03/21/24 07:30:07 UTC-4:00To: dev@kafka.apache.org Subject: [DISCUSS] KIP-1028: Docker Official Image for Apache Kafka Hi everyone, I would like to start the discussion on