Brad wrote:
> It might be easier to build a human intelligence than a dog
intelligence simply
> because we don't have a dog's perspective and we can't ask them to
reflect on it.
> Don't be quick to assume it would be easier just because they are less
intelligent.

Kevin wrote:
>  planning an intercept trajectory
> balance of the leap
> understanding body momentum
> understanding and using gravity
> control of hundreds of muscles
> ...

The point is not to pass a dog-turing-test, the point is to try and
abstract important features of intelligence that dogs, cats, chimps, and
humans all possess.  So I don't want to put up "dog specific" list items
like "mark territory with urine", even though this arguably is part of
doggie-smarts ;->.  What I'm really looking for are things that a dog,
stephen hawking, and helen keller all have.   In the next update of the
article, I'll definitely add a disclaimer to this effect..

Philip wrote:
> Dogs are social animals that live in packs (often).  There's nothing
on
 > the list about social behaviours.

Good point.  It has been argued that intelligence is correlated with
group size, and this should not be dismissed lightly.  However, I think
that there are fairly intelligent  animals that don't engage in _very
much_ socialization (e.g., leopards, hackers ;->).  I did put on the
list, "Imitation: recognizing that other entities are 'like myself'
(arguably a weak form of consciousness), and that the things that they
do are similar to the things I do, and trying to do some of the things
they do." which is a kind of social behavior.  This should probably be
expanded to encompas "theories of behavior" e.g., a theory of how sheep
behave, a theory of how humans behave,  etc..

Philip also wrote:
> Dogs are curious, they play, they have language skills - especially in

> terms of understanding what humans say

I think this is associative learning, rather that language.

Philip also also wrote:
> They can care for litters of 10 or so pups and they don't lose them so
they must
> have numeracy skills or some way of identifying which of the pups is
missing.

This is an important point that I hadn't considered.  I'm not sure
offhand whether dogs possess "numeracy" of the sort that this would seem
to indicate, and if so, how it is produced.  I'll have to do some
thinking...

> They've got a huge range of emotions - anger, joyfulness, curiosity,
> empathy, protectiveness, caring, fear, loneliness, aggression,
>  dominance.

Its debatable to what extent emotions actually contribute to
intelligence ;->.  Again, I'll have to think about this...

Thanks for all the constructive feedback!

Cheers,
Moshe


-------
To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, 
please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to