On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 20:52 -0500, Pavitra wrote:
> Kerim Aydin wrote:
> > I intend, without Objection, to register.
>
> I CFJ on the statement { If G.'s possible registration in the above
> message were successful, then G. would now be a party to the Fantasy
> Rules Contest. }, disqualifying ais523.
>
> Arguments:
>
> G.'s (conditional) deregistration didn't explicitly say e was invoking
> eir R101(vii) right, but e did mention the mousetrap as a factor in eir
> decision. Where do we draw the line between a "mundane" deregistration,
> which merely flips the Citizenship switch, and a "strong" R101(vii)
> deregistration, which disengages the deregistrator entirely from Agora?
>
> Note that this should not be in any way dependent on the outcome of G.'s
> recent CFJ on a related matter, as the hypothetical in the statement
> would mean that both eir registration and deregistration occurred.
There's no evidence that G. intends to stop playing Agora altogether
forever; quite the opposite, I would say.
--
ais523
