On Mon, 2026-07-13 at 17:38 +0300, msh210 via agora-discussion wrote:
> Galle wrote, in part:
> > I submit the following proposal, entitled "Unique CFJ IDs", with an
> > Adoption Index of 2:
> > ===
> > Amend Rule 991 ("Calls for Judgement") by replacing the eighth
> > paragraph with the following text:
> > ---
> > If a CFJ does not have a unique ID number, the Arbitor CAN by
> > announcement or by clear specification assign an unused ID number to
> > it, and SHALL do so in any message in which e assigns a player to
> > judge it.
> > ---
> > ===
> >
> > This is a fairly straightforward legislative clarification of my
> > recent CFJ, allowing the Arbitor to renumber CFJs in the event that e
> > accidentally assigns a non-unique one, and also hopefully blocking the
> > assignment of non-unique IDs altogether.
>
> But do we have a good archive of used IDs?
In addition to this issue, there's the issue that rules and proposals
also have ID numbers, and the rules read like those could not be used
for CFJs.
In terms of trying to figure out unused numbers: for a long time, Agora
had rules requiring numbers to be allocated sequentially, but there
were often escape hatches (e.g. allowing numbers to be allocated out of
sequence if there were a large batch of spam proposals or CFJs
submitted at once). There were also scams (e.g. the rule banned
choosing an out-of-sequence number unless any lower number would be
confusing, which made it possible to choose the number 1 on the basis
that using 0 or lower would be confusing). Those rules were also
repealed for a while recently. Still, in general we've had a pretty
much continuous sequence of ID numbers for CFJs (starting at 1) and
proposals (starting, IIUC, at 301) throughout most of Agora's history,
and thus numbers in the range between the most recently used number and
the first used number are likely to also have been used, and higher
numbers are likely not to have been.
Rule numbers are a bit different: I wasn't playing at the time, but
from what I've gathered from historical discussions rules were
originally given the number of the proposal that created them. (Suber's
original Nomic ruleset also renumbers amended rules to match the number
of the proposal that amended them; I'm not sure whether or not Agora
ever did that.) As such, any rule with an ID number in the 100-299
range was part of Agora's initial ruleset. 101 is a bit of an exception
because it has a historical tendency to have its text replaced outright
with something extremely different from the previous version,
technically keeping the history and number but practically creating a
new rule.
--
ais523