> From the Logical Ruleset published Nov 22, 1994 (regrettably, the next 
> available snapshot I have), at some point amended rules stopped being 
> renumbered:
>
>   Rule 109/0 (Semimutable, MI=3)
>   Rule and Proposal Numbers
>
>     The Speaker shall give each Proposal which has been proposed in
>     the proper way a Number for reference.  The Number assigned to a
>     given Proposal shall be the least integer greater than all
>     Numbers previously assigned, or 301, whichever is greater.  No
>     Proposal may have the same Number as any previous Proposal.
>
>     When a Rule is Created, it receives the Number of the Proposal
>     to Create it.  Once created, a Rule shall not have its Number
>     changed, except as specified in the Rules.
>
>   History:
>   ...
>   Renumbered from 1067 to 109 by Rule 1295, Nov. 1 1994
>
> Rules 1295 and 1067 escape my archives, but it appears 1295 renumbered, at a 
> minimum:
>   - 1067 to 109 "Rule and Proposal Numbers" (above)
>   - 1072 to 105 "What Is a Rule Change?"
>   - 1073 to 106 "Adopting Proposals"
>   - 1074 to 108 "When May Rule Changes Take Effect?"
>   - 1077 to 114 "Rules Can Always Be Changed"
>

Realized this didn't actually discuss the juicy bit of rules being amended 
(except by omission). Thought I'd supplement with another rule from that 
ruleset.

It seems that the ballpark of either Proposal 750 or 1069 is the most likely 
candidate for when rules stopped being renumbered by amendments:

  Rule 1069 (Mutable, MI=1)
  Amendment Indices

    Let there be a number known as the Amendment Index, which is
    appended to a Rule's Number, separated by a forward slash, and
    which is equal to the number of times a Rule with that Number
    has been Amended. The default Amendment Index is zero; this is
    the value of a Rule's Amendment Index when the Rule is Created,
    and it is the value of the Amendment Index of every Rule unless
    it is specified by the Rules to be otherwise.

    If the Amendment Index of a Rule is zero, the Amendment Index
    need not be displayed with the text of the Rule. Otherwise, the
    Amendment Index shall be displayed in Official copies of the
    Ruleset, along with the Number and text of the Rule.
    Responsibility is given to the Rulekeepor to accurately update
    the Amendment Index.

    In addition, when a Rule is Amended, the Rulekeepor shall
    append to the text of the Rule an annotation giving the number
    of the Amendment, the Number of the Proposal which Amended the
    Rule, and the date on which this Proposal passed.

    Amendment Indices may be used for Official purposes and in
    Official documents to distinguish between old versions of a
    Rule and the Rule's current text.
    (*Was: 750*)

In this ruleset, rules contain `(*Was: X*) up until X=1025, and the earliest 
proposal with an "Amended" annotation is

  Amended(1) by Proposal 1270, Oct. 24 1994

giving me very high confidence in proposals around 1069 disabling rule 
amendment. The earliest annotation of any FLR-style history is in Oct 1994, so 
it doesn't actually tell us much about the date other than "this is when the 
rulekeepor started including history annotations".

kiako, Archivist, Webmastor

Reply via email to