> Rule numbers are a bit different: I wasn't playing at the time, but
> from what I've gathered from historical discussions rules were
> originally given the number of the proposal that created them.
> (Suber's original Nomic ruleset also renumbers amended rules to match
> the number of the proposal that amended them; I'm not sure whether or
> not Agora ever did that.)

I can confirm from my archive crawl this was the case for Agora.



>From the Logical Ruleset published Aug 28, 1993, we see that initially, all 
>created and amended rules were given the number of the proposal:

  Rule 109 (Immutable)

    The Speaker shall give each proposed Rule Change a Number for
    reference.  The numbers shall begin with 301, and each Rule Change
    proposed in the proper way shall receive the next successive
    integer, whether or not the Proposal is adopted.

    If a Rule is Repealed and Reenacted, it receives the Number of the
    Proposal to Reenact it.  If a Rule is Amended or Transmuted, it
    receives the Number of the Proposal to Amend or Transmute it.

  History:
  Initial Rule 109

(For benchmarking, the highest numbered proposal/rule mentioned on Aug 28 is 
392)



>From the Logical Ruleset published Nov 22, 1994 (regrettably, the next 
>available snapshot I have), at some point amended rules stopped being 
>renumbered:

  Rule 109/0 (Semimutable, MI=3)
  Rule and Proposal Numbers

    The Speaker shall give each Proposal which has been proposed in
    the proper way a Number for reference.  The Number assigned to a
    given Proposal shall be the least integer greater than all
    Numbers previously assigned, or 301, whichever is greater.  No
    Proposal may have the same Number as any previous Proposal.

    When a Rule is Created, it receives the Number of the Proposal
    to Create it.  Once created, a Rule shall not have its Number
    changed, except as specified in the Rules.

  History:
  ...
  Renumbered from 1067 to 109 by Rule 1295, Nov. 1 1994

Rules 1295 and 1067 escape my archives, but it appears 1295 renumbered, at a 
minimum:
  - 1067 to 109 "Rule and Proposal Numbers" (above)
  - 1072 to 105 "What Is a Rule Change?"
  - 1073 to 106 "Adopting Proposals"
  - 1074 to 108 "When May Rule Changes Take Effect?"
  - 1077 to 114 "Rules Can Always Be Changed"



>From the Logical Ruleset published July 20, 1995 (once again, the next 
>available snapshot), we see that created rules were assigned sequentially, 
>rather than by proposal ID, starting with Rule 1349:

  Rule 1349/0 (Mutable, MI=1)
  Rule Numbering

    The Rulekeepor shall give each newly-enacted Rule a Number for
    reference when it is created.  The Number of a Rule shall be the
    least integer greater than all other Numbers previously given to
    a Rule (including numbers assigned to Rules later determined to
    have been incorrectly enacted), or 301, whichever is greater.

    Once a Rule has been given a Rule Number, it shall not be
    changed except as specified in the Rules.

  History:
  Created by Proposal 1349, Nov. 29 1994



kiako, Archivist, Webmastor

Reply via email to