On Tue, Sep 1, 2026 at 5:03 AM kiako via agora-discussion < [email protected]> wrote:
> Hi all, > > Given the 3(?) recent cases in Agora of LLMs being employed by players > (automated and otherwise), the Discord's been discussing if we need a clear > stance on LLMs and "agents" in Agora. To keep the conversation archived & > accessible, I'm moving it to the list. > > I'd appreciate if those with vested interest in Agora could chip in their > opinions. > > Some convo starters: > > * What do you think of LLMs in/for Agora? > * What do you think of automated or "agentic" LLMs participating in Agora > (those that would send messages without human prompting or vetting)? > * Would allowing/prohibiting LLMs (automated/"agentic" or otherwise) > affect your participation in Agora (positively or negatively)? > > I do ask that if comments are being generated or sent by an > automated/"agentic" LLM workflow for this conversation, it should > explicitly be stated as such. > > I'll be sending my thoughts in a separate message. Thanks for opening this conversation. I suspect I'm less anti-LLM in my leanings in general than a lot of players. However, the biggest factor for me is that Agora is a game. I'd prefer to be playing with actual people, who can understand what I'm saying. As we've pretty clearly established at this point, LLMs aren't people in that sense. The problem then becomes a line drawing exercise. I think the biggest initial problem here are agentic LLMs, which I believe we should be banning outright. I just don't want to be playing with AI agents instead of players, full-stop. This also where AI's inability to actually understand what they're doing hits hardest, due to the lack of immediate supervision. I personally find people using AIs to generate content only they will read (e.g. "search the ruleset for rules about X") relatively inoffensive, although I'm concerned about accuracy. Agora is a game where repeatedly being inaccurate can negatively impact other players. I also don't really mind people using AI for game-related coding tasks; that's become increasingly standard, whether one likes it or not, and I don't think a blanket ban makes sense. We've always allowed officers a lot of discretion in how they compiled their reports for instance; saying "no AI generation of report code" would be a break with that tradition. Furthermore, such code isn't game text, and thus sort of falls under the "no one else will have to read this" criterion. So for me, right now, the biggest open question is non-agentic AI generation of text that other people will have to read. And here it's like... IDK, AI proofing doesn't seem that bad to me? But there's a fine line between "check this for errors and fix them" and "rewrite this" and the latter gets close to what I think we might want to ban. Outright generation of messages, like "write an Agoran contract saying X", should probably be banned I think. Those are my initial thoughts. I haven't been engaged in prior discussions and I'm very willing to listen to what others have to say and adjust my opinions. I'm also sympathetic to the fact that others may have much stronger emotional reactions on this topic than I do. -Aris

