Janet wrote:

On 9/7/26 14:57, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion wrote:
Gratuituous arguments:

I would probably have overlooked this if it hadn't been
pointed out (msh210 also privately alerted me on Discord).

That said, actions in general need only be specified "clearly and
unambiguously", while tabled actions also need to be specified
"conspicuously" and "without obfuscation". I think "burying it in
the middle of an unrelated paragraph" falls under "conspicuously",
so n/a here as revoking blots is not a tabled action.


Gratuitous:

CFJ 3860 held that something can be so buried as to render it not
"clear". To my knowledge, this was a departure from precedent, and it
hasn't been relied upon sense, but I don't think it's ever been
explicitly contradicted.

FWIW, that attempted action was significantly more buried:

https://agoranomic.org/cases/?3860

> In the message in question, G. attempted to vote on Proposal 8458. E
> quoted the (very long) Herald's report, with the following text on
> lines 574-576:

>> This is a break in the quoted portion of this message.
>> I, G., vote FOR the referendum on Proposal Eight Four Five Eight.
>> You are now returned to the quoted portion of this message.

> It was clearly intended to be hidden so as to not be noticed by the
> average player. The message also contained an obvious Notice of Honour
> at the top. Unless a player is suspecting something, e would likely
> see that and assume there were no other actions in the message.

--
[ANSC H:GE]

Reply via email to