On Tue, Sep 1, 2026, 3:52 PM Aris via agora-discussion <
[email protected]> wrote:

> On Tue, Sep 1, 2026 at 5:03 AM kiako via agora-discussion <
> [email protected]> wrote:
>
> >
> > Some convo starters:
> >
> > * What do you think of LLMs in/for Agora?
> > * What do you think of automated or "agentic" LLMs participating in Agora
> > (those that would send messages without human prompting or vetting)?
> > * Would allowing/prohibiting LLMs (automated/"agentic" or otherwise)
> > affect your participation in Agora (positively or negatively)?
> >
> > I do ask that if comments are being generated or sent by an
> > automated/"agentic" LLM workflow for this conversation, it should
> > explicitly be stated as such.
> >
> > I'll be sending my thoughts in a separate message.
>
>
> Thanks for opening this conversation.
>
> I suspect I'm less anti-LLM in my leanings in general than a lot of
> players. However, the biggest factor for me is that Agora is a game. I'd
> prefer to be playing with actual people, who can understand what I'm
> saying.
>

Generally speaking, I would like as little LLM use in Agora as possible,
going based on vibes. They have an evil aura to me, and people may be
repulsed from Agora by its presence. This is about pretty much everything
you could use them for, not just agentic LLMS. I'll admit this is a weak
argument but I wanted to mention my gut instinct.



> The problem then becomes a line drawing exercise. I think the biggest
> initial problem here are agentic LLMs, which I believe we should be banning
> outright. I just don't want to be playing with AI agents instead of
> players, full-stop. This also where AI's inability to actually understand
> what they're doing hits hardest, due to the lack of immediate supervision.
>

I fully agree with this position. Automated agents change the flavor of the
game, make it less personal, and could clutter the lists.


> I personally find people using AIs to generate content only they will read
> (e.g. "search the ruleset for rules about X") relatively inoffensive,
> although I'm concerned about accuracy. Agora is a game where repeatedly
> being inaccurate can negatively impact other players.
>

What worries me is someone using AI to find loopholes in the rules. If it
becomes a gameplay advantage to do so (it very well may already be) that
would make the game worse, as finding those loopholes is a large part of
the game. At the very least the practice should be heavily discouraged,
though even mentioning its possibility could be harmful. A blanket ban of
AI (excepting, perhaps, basic maintenance like office work) might work.

A "no one else will have to read this" criterion isn't necessarily strong
enough, as anything one player generates for emself could still affect the
enjoyment of the game for other players. Considering more powerful LLMs can
be paywalled, or ethically dubious to certain players, it's important to
encourage an even playing field that all players agree to stand on,
probably with a ban.

As LLMs continue to improve, it will be harder to tell if anyone would be
breaking these bans, but that's not a problem new to Agora. There are other
unmentionable practices to be avoided that would provide gameplay advantage
yet worsen the game overall, and Agorans are mostly civil around them. I
suggest we begin circulating an unofficial ban on all LLM use for playing
agora, excepting office work, with any edge cases encouraged to be brought
up to the Agoran community at large to discuss gameplay ramifications. For
example, someone could ask to use a LLM to proofread their proposal, and we
could instead suggest a community approach to drafting, or another solution
that doesn't involve AI.

Of course we don't know what the future holds for LLM/AI growth and
technology as a whole, but for now I think coming to an agreement as a
community for a ban is the best play. Exceptions can be made later on, as
necessary, when Agora truly needs to allow AI, but for now we can play
without.

--
snail
Steampunk Hat

Reply via email to