Proto-Proposal: Winning and losing conditions
(AI = 3)

[Reviving a generalized win framework, previously adopted in 2008 and
 later removed as part of a mass repeal in 2011.

https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2011-January/008542.html
]

Re-enact Rule 2186 (Victory) with Power 2 and this text:

      Winning Conditions and Losing Conditions are conditions defined
      as such by the rules.  If such a condition is defined by the
      rules as being satisfied when an event occurs (as opposed to
      being satisfied while certain other conditions hold), then it
      thereafter continues to be satisfied until the rules explicitly
      say otherwise.

      When one or more persons satisfy at least one Winning Condition
      and do not satisfy any Losing Conditions, all such persons win
      the game.  The game CANNOT be won in any other way, rules to the
      contrary notwithstanding.

      Each Winning Condition should (if needed) specify a cleanup
      procedure to prevent an arbitrary number of wins arising from
      essentially the same conditions.  When one or more persons win
      the game:

        a) For each Winning Condition satisfied by at least one of
           those persons, its cleanup procedure (if any) occurs.

        b) Each of those persons ceases to satisfy any Winning
           Conditions.

      A win announcement is an announcement meeting all of these
      requirements:

        a) It is factually correct.

        b) It is explicitly labeled as a win announcement and/or
           clearly states that one or more persons thereby win the
           game.

        c) If it was a win announcement, then it would cause one or
           more Winning Conditions to be satisfied, as defined by
           other rules.

[Should be the same as before. Apart from providing a generic
 framework, the main feature is that Losing Conditions don't cause
 you to miss out on a win entirely, they merely delay it until you
 clear all your Losing Conditions.]

Re-enact Rule 2245 (Win by Not Losing) with Power 1 and this text:

      While a player is the only active player not to satisfy at least
      one Losing Condition, e satisfies the Winning Condition of
      Solitude.

      Cleanup procedure:  The same person cannot satisfy this Winning
      Condition again until at least one other player ceases to
      satisfy any Losing Condition.

[Removes a reference to "first-class" players, previously used to
 exclude legal persons.]

[Now that the framework is re-enacted, update existing win conditions
 to use it.]

Amend Rule 2614 (Eclipse Light) by replacing this text:

        - Cause one or more players to win Agora.

with this text:

        - Cause one or more players to satisfy Winning Conditions.
        - Cause one or more players to cease to satisfy Losing
          Conditions.

Amend Rule 2556 (Penalties) by replacing this text:

      Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, an impure person CANNOT win
      the game.

with this text:

      Being impure is a Losing Condition.

Amend Rule 2659 (Stamps) by replacing this text:

      When e does so, e wins the game.

with this text:

      Upon doing so, e satisfies the Winning Condition of Collection.

Amend Rule 2711 (Outshining the Sun) to read:

      Upon a win announcement from a player that eir radiance is 100 or
      more, e satisfies the Winning Condition of Outshining the Sun.

      Cleanup procedure: The following happen in order:

      * Each player satisfying this condition (hereafter the Luminaries)
        has eir radiance set to 0.

      * Each player not satisfying this condition (hereafter the Dim
        Ones) has eir radiance set to half its current value (rounded
        down).

      * Each Luminary has all eir Pyrite destroyed.

      * Each Dim One retains half eir Pyrite (rounded down), or 4000,
        whichever is less, and has the rest destroyed.

      * The Fields Wither.

      * All Hectares are destroyed.

      * Each player is granted 16 Hectares.

      * Each non-winning Luminary satisfies the Winning Condition of
        Having Outshone the Sun.

[Wins delayed by a Losing Condition can still happen later, but don't
 re-trigger the cleanup procedure.]

Amend Rule 2465 (Victory by Apathy) by replacing this text:

      A player CAN Declare Apathy without objection, specifying a set of
      players. Upon doing so, the specified players win the game, except
      for those who have won the game through this Rule in the past 14
      days.

with this text:

      A player CAN Declare Apathy without objection, specifying a set of
      players. Upon doing so, the specified players satisfy the Winning
      Condition of Whatever.

      Cleanup procedure: The players satisfying this condition cannot do
      so again for 14 days.

Amend Rule 2553 (Win by Paradox) to read:

      Upon a win announcement specifying a CFJ that

        a) was initiated by the announcer,

        b) was about the effectiveness, possibility, or legality of a
           change in the gamestate, and

        c) has been assigned a judgement of PARADOXICAL continuously for
           between 7 and 90 days,

      e satisfies the Winning Condition of Transcending Logic.

      Cleanup procedure: Each person satisfying this condition cannot do
      so again for the same CFJ or any other CFJ linked to it, and
      SHOULD make a reasonable attempt to resolve the paradox and
      prevent it from arising again.

[Cleanup generalized along the lines of its predecessor, Rule 2110.]

Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing this text:

      While a person owns all types of Ribbon, that person can Raise a
      Banner by announcement. This causes that person to win the game.
      When a person wins this way, for each type of Ribbon, that
      person's <type> Ribbon Ownership is flipped to False.

with this text:

      Upon owning all types of Ribbon, a person satisfies the Winning
      Condition of Renaissance. (Cleanup procedure: For each person
      satisfying this condition and each type of Ribbon, eir <type>
      Ribbon Ownership is flipped to False.)

Amend Rule 2464 (Tournaments) by replacing this text:

      Each time that one or more winners of a tournament are determined
      before it concludes, that person or those persons win the game.

with this text:

      Upon a tournament having one or more winners determined before it
      concludes, those persons satisfy the Winning Condition of
      Quintaining.

Amend Rule 2695 (The Veblen) by replacing this text:

      If the Veblen does not exist and no one has Created Something E
      Cannot Destroy in the past week, any player CAN, by announcement,
      Create Something E Cannot Destroy. When e does so, e wins the
      game, and the Veblen is created in eir possession. A player who
      wins in this fashion SHOULD submit a proposal to prevent the
      destruction from arising again.

with this text:

      Upon a win announcement that the Veblen does not exist, the
      Veblen is created in the announcer's possession, and e satisfies
      the Winning Condition of Creating the Indestructible. (Cleanup
      procedure: e SHOULD submit a proposal to prevent the Veblen from
      being destroyed in the same fashion.)

Amend Rule 2702 (Agoran Bingo) by replacing this text:

      When a player successfully calls bingo, e wins the game and the
      bingo state is flipped to paused.

with this text:

      Upon successfully calling bingo, a player satisfies the Winning
      Condition of Bingo. (Cleanup procedure: The bingo state is
      flipped to paused.)

--

Proto-Proposal: You're only president for life

Re-enact Rule 2223 (Win by Junta) with Power 1 and this text:

      Upon a win announcement that a rule states that one or more
      persons CAN cause it to make arbitrary rule changes by
      announcement, all those persons satisfy the Winning Condition of
      Dictatorship.

      Cleanup procedure:  Those persons SHALL as soon as possible
      amend the rule so that it no longer states this, and SHOULD
      amend the rules to prevent this condition from being achieved
      again in essentially the same way.

[Removes a reference to a specific dictatorship that existed at the
 time. Compare Rule 2438 allowing instruments to award Black Ribbons,
 implicitly a lesser reward for less extensive self-interested rules
 or proposals.]

--

Proto-Proposal: Atrophy
(AI = 3)

Amend Rule 2646 (Activity) by appending this text:

      Having been inactive within the past week is a Losing Condition.

[Based on its predecessor, Rule 2130.]

--

Proto-Proposal: Untouchable
(AI = 1.7)

Re-enact Rule 2312 (The Pariah) with Power 1.7 and this text:

      The Pariah is an elected office, with no reports. Whenever a
      player becomes the Pariah, that player is awarded 23 Blots.

      If more than 6 Blots are destroyed in the Pariah's possession in
      any given week, the Pariah is awarded a sufficient number of
      Blots in order to bring eir net Blot loss that week up to no
      more than 6.

      Players are ENCOURAGED to enforce penalties for rules breaches
      against the Pariah, even really minor ones.

      Upon a win announcement that the Pariah has ever continuously
      had 0 Blots for an entire week whilst being the Pariah for all
      of that time, then the Pariah satisfies the Winning Condition of
      Cleanliness. Cleanup condition: The office of Pariah becomes
      vacant and that player ceases to satisfy this Winning Condition.

[Renames "Rests", the Notes economy's version of Blots.]

--

Proto-Proposal: Some voters are more equal than others
(AI = 2)

Re-enact Rule 2134 (Win by Clout) with Power 2 and this text:

      Upon a win announcement that a specified player's voting strength
      on an ordinary decision initiated at that time would exceed the
      combined voting strength of all other players on that decision,
      the specified player satisfies the Winning Condition of Clout.

      Cleanup procedure:  No player can satisfy this Winning Condition
      again during the same month.

[Renames "voting limit" to "voting strength". Removes a reference to
 chambers, a system similar to the recent Color proto that affected
 voting strength on ordinary proposals, as well as a "notwithstanding"
 clause that's now covered by Rule 2240.]

--

Proto-Proposal: Bribery

Re-enact Rule 2188 (Win by Proposal) with Power 1 and this text:

      Upon a win announcement that a proposal awarding a win to one or
      more persons has been adopted, all those persons satisfy the
      Winning Condition of Legislation.

      Cleanup procedure: None of those persons can satisfy the
      condition again for the same proposal.

[Should be unchanged.]

--

Proto-Proposal: Fly, be free!

Re-enact Rule 2287 (Props) with Power 1 and this text:

      Props are a currency.

      The Air Traffic Controller is an office and the recordkeepor of
      props.

      Ownership of props is limited to players.  Props CANNOT be
      created, transferred, or destroyed except as allowed by this rule
      or required by the rules in general.

      Once per week, each player CAN transfer a prop from one player
      to another, provided that e explains why e chose each player,
      and does not transfer it to emself.

      At the beginning of each quarter, one prop in the possession of
      each player possessing more than fourteen props is destroyed,
      and one prop is created in the possession of each player
      possessing less than fourteen props.

      Players with at least 19 props are Pilots; the Pilot with the
      most props (if any) is the Captain. Players with less than 9
      props are Marines.  As soon as possible after any of these
      statuses change, the Air Traffic Controller SHALL announce it.

      Upon a win announcement that one or more players each possess at
      least 30 props, all those players satisfy the Winning Condition
      of Respect.

      Cleanup procedure: All props are destroyed and 14 props are
      created in the possession of each player.

[Removes "first-class". Moves initial allocation to Rule 2499.]

Amend Rule 2499 (Welcome Packages) by adding this text after the item
about gaining spendies:

      * gains 14 props;

--

I'm skipping Rule 2293 (Leadership Tokens), which depended on several
other rules that would be much more complicated to revive, mainly an
Order of Succession to the Speakership (with various perks and an
option to start Rebellions). Compare to the Oligarchy, another past
system where higher positions had more voting strength, but the
highest was term-limited at one month.

--
[ANSC H:GE]

Reply via email to