> On Oct 4, 2026, at 4:01 PM, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion > <[email protected]> wrote: > > Amend Rule 2614 (Eclipse Light) by replacing this text: > > - Cause one or more players to win Agora. > > with this text: > > - Cause one or more players to satisfy Winning Conditions. > - Cause one or more players to cease to satisfy Losing > Conditions.
As ais523 pointed out, there's a problem here where most Losing Conditions are evaluated continuously, rather than being something that can be turned on and off. There's also the additional problem that "satisfy Winning Conditions" is ambiguous - which winning conditions? I agree that probably the simplest solution is just to have emergency proposal wins overrule the framework. > Proto-Proposal: Untouchable > (AI = 1.7) > > Re-enact Rule 2312 (The Pariah) with Power 1.7 and this text: > > The Pariah is an elected office, with no reports. Whenever a > player becomes the Pariah, that player is awarded 23 Blots. > > If more than 6 Blots are destroyed in the Pariah's possession in > any given week, the Pariah is awarded a sufficient number of > Blots in order to bring eir net Blot loss that week up to no > more than 6. > > Players are ENCOURAGED to enforce penalties for rules breaches > against the Pariah, even really minor ones. > > Upon a win announcement that the Pariah has ever continuously > had 0 Blots for an entire week whilst being the Pariah for all > of that time, then the Pariah satisfies the Winning Condition of > Cleanliness. Cleanup condition: The office of Pariah becomes > vacant and that player ceases to satisfy this Winning Condition. > > [Renames "Rests", the Notes economy's version of Blots.] I like the idea in theory, but think that it will in practice make for somewhat boring gameplay unless the Pariah is under some pressure to actively do things besides get rid of blots, it's not hard to avoid breaking the rules currently. > Proto-Proposal: Fly, be free! > > Re-enact Rule 2287 (Props) with Power 1 and this text: > > Props are a currency. > > The Air Traffic Controller is an office and the recordkeepor of > props. > > Ownership of props is limited to players. Props CANNOT be > created, transferred, or destroyed except as allowed by this rule > or required by the rules in general. These three paragraphs can be simplified to: "Props are a fixed, indestructible currency ownable by players. The Air Traffic Controller is an office and the recordkeepor of props." It should probably also be specified that transferring props is done by announcement. - Galle, Speaker and Champion

